Emily Clements, in a 2012 essay, wrote: "One of Tony Hillerman's strengths as a writer is his ability to make what would otherwise appear to be a foreign culture seem familiar".
Kirkus Reviews finds this novel "less absorbing" than other works by Hillerman, but "ultimately powerful". Mark Harris writing in the
Chicago Tribune observes that "When a novel of mystery rises above its mere classification-"mystery"- and becomes a fine literary work it offers that dimension of atmosphere
Maugham mentions ... In this case, it is the sense the author imparts of the sparseness, the spaciousness, the silence, the poverty and the ancient sullen Indian presence in this haunted wild country where the action occurs." ==Reference in other novels==