Tale type According to scholar
Jack Zipes, the tale is classified in the international
Aarne-Thompson-Uther Index as type ATU 328, "The Boy Steals the Ogre's Treasure". The title of the Sicilian tale,
Tridicinu, is also the name of tale type ATU 328 in the Italian index of tales of magic. In the Italian tale type, thirteen brothers take shelter in an ogre's house who threatens to devour them, but they escape to a castle; however, the hero's elder brothers lie that their sibling can return to the ogre's lair to steal his objects (usually three) and, lastly, to bring the ogre himself. According to Kurt Ranke, some scholars (
Grimm Brothers,
Johannes Bolte and ) have noticed great similarities between tale types ATU 328 and ATU 531, even proposing some deeper connection between both types, since they also appear in combination with each other due to their narrative contents. Liungman, for example, argued that type ATU 531 originated type ATU 328.
Motifs In some tales, the hero has no blood relation to his rivals, and in others the hero is helped by a magic horse. In the latter case, the story develops as type AT 531. According to Aprile, this occurs in a group of "typically
Sicilian" variants.
The hero's name According to
Stith Thompson's second revision of the tale type index, tale type 328 contains the
motif L10.1.1, "«Thirteenth» name of victorious youngest son". In addition, German scholar
Kurt Ranke, in
Enzyklopädie des Märchens, noted that in
Yugoslavian,
Rhaeto-Romance, Italian and Greek variants, the hero is known as some variation of the number "Thirteenth". == Variants ==