This Godless Endeavor ranked at number 2 in
Unrestrained! magazine's top 20 albums of 2005. It was also ranked #88 on the October 2006 issue of
Guitar World magazine's list of the greatest 100 guitar albums of all time.
AllMusic's Eduardo Rivadavia praised "the soaring vocals of Warrel Dane and lead guitar heroics of Jeff Loomis" as "twin beacons shining out from the band's gloriously metallic bulk." He declared, "Don't forget the near-nine-minute title track, which culminates in what must surely stand as one of Nevermore's most consistent LPs in suitably epic fashion. Indeed, American-bred heavy metal doesn't get any better than this." The album's review in
PopMatters noted the complex influences, highlighting "traces of '80s progressive metal greats such as
Queensrÿche,
Savatage, and
Fates Warning," as well as "monstrous doses of European elements, such as blazingly fast
tempos, tautly performed arrangements, and unrelenting
blastbeats." In one of PopMatters' only complaints, the song "Bittersweet Feast" was considered "one track too many on an otherwise extraordinary album." Overall, within Nevermore's catalog,
This Godless Endeavor was touted as "yet another chapter in what has become one of the more impressive album streaks in recent metal history." The German
Rock Hard voted it "Album of the Month" and called it "the best and most intense metal album of the decade." The album was later ranked number 256 in their book
The 500 Greatest Rock & Metal Albums of All Time. ==Track listing==