Jack Gould's review in
The New York Times expressed concern over the invasion of subjects' privacy on
This Is Your Life. Gould cited an episode featuring an elderly widower, describing the broadcast as "a carefully staged orgy of embarrassing sentimentality". He mentioned on-the-air appearances by the man's children and other relatives and Edwards's allusion to the death of the man's wife and summarized, "The whole incident was as inexcusable as it was needless. Personal human emotions should be exempt from such reckless abuse." Even so, he said, "The
This Is Your Life treatment gives even the most ordinary life a touch of drama ... the show nearly always offers a full share of real pathos, excitement and humor." Crosby compared an episode about a paraplegic war veteran to the exposure of a raw nerve. Haughner's review complimented the research and documentation behind each episode. He added, however, that Edwards "can turn on and off his 'tenderness' voice with trigger-like
rapidity", leading Haughner to "wonder if there isn't more hokum to the show than meets the eye and ear". The review noted the ill-at-ease feeling conveyed by the guest on the episode reviewed and added, "The listener begins to feel like an intruder." The reviewer commended the thoroughness of the research done in preparation for the episode. The review said that the "necessarily amateurish talent involved" hampered the effectiveness of the broadcasts. It pointed out the ineffective communication of the reticent guest's reactions as relatives and friends appeared. Despite such shortcomings, the review said, "Edwards handled the show well, especially in the early parts when it sagged badly." ==Adaptation==