Neibaur spent several months in
field hospitals recovering from his wounds. His last wound by a German machine gun bullet remained in his hip the rest of his life. Neibaur also represented the first private in the U.S. Army to receive the Medal of Honor. On February 9, 1919, at the AEF headquarters at
Chaumont, France, Pershing presented the Medal of Honor to him, along with a dozen other officers and soldiers. He married Sarah "Lois" Shepard in November 1919; she was six years older than him and had a son from a previous marriage. Discouraged by his misfortune, Neibaur mailed his Medal of Honor and other decorations to Congress in Washington stating that "I cannot eat them." Local newspapers covered the story. Three days later he secured a position as a night security officer at the state capitol in
Boise. His wife Lois died in 1940, at the age of forty-eight from complications of rheumatic fever she had contracted in childhood. His awards and decorations were returned to Mrs. Lillian Neibaur who donated them to the Idaho State Historical Society. ==Military decorations==