The publication of his
Narrative led, once public opinion had turned against the informers, to his trial for
libel (Kenyon notes that he could not as the law stood be tried for
perjury, as no-one had actually been convicted on his evidence). Dangerfield went into hiding in 1684 as soon as he heard about the threatened trial, but when James succeeded as King in February 1685 the new Government made a determined search for him and found him. He was tried and speedily convicted. On 20 June 1685 he received his sentence, which was to stand in the
pillory on two consecutive days, be whipped from
Aldgate to
Newgate, and two days later from Newgate to
Tyburn. On his way back from the first whipping on 22 June Dangerfield, who rather surprisingly was travelling by
coach, got into an argument at
Hatton Garden with a
barrister, Robert Francis, who made a jeering remark, on the lines of "How do you, after your little race?" Dangerfield in return spat on him and called him a son of a whore, whereupon Francis struck Dangerfield in the eye with his cane: the cane apparently entered the brain, and Dangerfield died shortly afterwards from the blow. Francis was tried and convicted for
murder, and sentenced to death, despite his insistence that he never meant to kill Dangerfield. Several witnesses testified that on the contrary he had deliberately stabbed at Dangerfield's eye, and there was also some evidence that he had said that "he would save the hangman the trouble of killing Dangerfield". Nonetheless the verdict of murder came as a surprise to the public, the general view being that the death "could scarce be even called
manslaughter".
Sir John Reresby wrote that he was sure that Francis had had no intention of killing Dangerfield, "for he had a sword by his side, which was a more likely thing to kill him than that little cane, indeed the smallest that ever I saw". King
James II was solicited strongly to grant Francis a
royal pardon, on the basis of his previously blameless life, but, despite his low opinion of Dangerfield, he said that it would be wrong to let his murderer go unpunished, and Francis was duly executed on 24 July 1685.
Sir John Bramston in a contemptuous epitaph wrote that Dangerfield deserved no pity: "he had been a highway thief, a cheat, a little rogue.. but there is an end of him". ==The Narrative - aftermath==