Butler stood as an unsuccessful candidate for reelection in 1889. He was a delegate to the
Republican National Convention in 1892. and an unidentified
Marine Lieutenant returning from France aboard in August 1919. Elected to Congress in his first term as an
Independent Republican, he was elected as a
Republican for each succeeding term. While in Congress, he was chairman of the
United States House Committee on Pacific Railroads (
Fifty-ninth through
Sixty-first Congresses) and member of the
United States House Committee on Naval Affairs (
Sixty-sixth through
Seventieth Congresses). During
World War I, Butler read into the Congressional Record the "bogus oath", which was falsely attributed to the Roman Catholic fraternal organization
Knights of Columbus, in which the oath taker pledges to war against Protestant Christians. The bogus oath was refuted by the
Committee on Public Information, the wartime information agency of the
Woodrow Wilson administration. Butler died in office and was buried in
Oaklands Cemetery, West Chester, Pennsylvania. His home at West Chester,
The Butler House, was listed on the
National Register of Historic Places in 1980. ==See also==