Ancient Rome '' (1872) by
Jean-Léon Gérôme is one of the sources of the "thumbs down" gesture in modern
popular culture, but is not based on historical data from Ancient Rome. The
Latin phrase
pollice verso is used in the context of
gladiatorial combat for a hand gesture used by
Ancient Roman crowds to pass judgment on a defeated gladiator. While it is clear that the thumb was involved, the precise type of gesture described by the phrase
pollice verso and its meaning are unclear in the historical and literary record. According to
Anthony Corbeill, a
classical studies professor who has extensively researched the practice, thumbs up signalled killing the gladiator while "a closed fist with a wraparound thumb" meant sparing him. In modern popular culture it is wrongly presumed that "thumbs down" was the signal that a defeated gladiator should be condemned to
death; "thumbs up", that he should be spared.
Middle Ages It has been suggested that 'thumbs up' was a signal from English archers preparing for battle that all is well with their bow and they are ready to fight. Before use, the
fistmele (or the "brace height") was checked, that being the distance between the string and the bow on an English
longbow. This fistmele should be about , which is about the same as a fist with a thumb extended. The term fistmele is a Saxon word that refers to that measurement.
Desmond Morris in
Gestures: Their Origins and Distribution traces the practice back to a
medieval custom used to seal business transactions, suggesting that over time, the mere sight of an upraised thumb came to symbolize harmony and kind feelings. For example, see the seventeenth-century
Diego Velázquez painting
The Lunch.
20th century The
Oxford English Dictionary cites the earliest written instance of "thumbs-up" (with a positive meaning) as being from
Over the Top, a 1917 book written by
Arthur Guy Empey. Empey was an American who served in the British armed forces during
World War I. He wrote: "Thumbs up,
Tommy’s expression which means ‘everything is fine with me'." A visual example of the British use of "thumbs up" having a positive meaning (or, "
okay") from the 1920s can be seen 19 minutes into the British-made silent 1927 film
The Lodger: A Story of the London Fog, where the younger man examines some paper money for the older man and declares it "good" (not counterfeit) with a "thumbs up" using both hands. Popularization in the United States is generally attributed to the practices of
World War II pilots, who used the thumbs up to communicate with ground crews before take-off. This custom may have originated with the China-based
Flying Tigers, who were among the first American flyers involved in World War II. The appreciative Chinese would say
ting hao de (挺好的) meaning "very good", and gesture with a thumbs up, which in Chinese means "you're number one". High officials in the Chinese government see it as a sign of respect. During World War II, pilots on US
aircraft carriers adopted the thumbs-up gesture to alert the deck crew that they were ready to go and that the wheel chocks could be removed. On modern US carriers, specific deck crew hold a thumb up to signal to the pilot and control tower that their station is OK for take-off. American
GIs are reputed to have picked up on the thumb gesture and spread it throughout
Europe as they marched toward
Berlin.
21st century monk giving the common thumb sign of approval On July 28, 2017, when Senator
John McCain of Arizona cast the deciding vote that derailed a
Republican repeal attempt of the
Affordable Care Act ("Obamacare"), he used the thumbs down gesture. == International usage ==