Box office In the United States and Canada, the film made $242,269 from 16 theaters in its opening weekend. It held this record as the highest platform release opening of the year until
The Whale two months later. In its second weekend the film made $363,541 from 104 theaters. Expanding to 2,058 theaters in its third weekend, the film made $1.03 million on its first day and would go on to gross $2.7 million over the weekend, finishing sixth. In its second weekend of wide release the film made $1.88 million (marking a drop of 32%).
Variety attributed these results to the general public showing the early stages of refusal to see and support
prestige films in theaters in a moviegoing environment altered by the
COVID-19 pandemic, along with the possibility that the film's subject matter may have been seen as uncomfortable for audiences to handle.
Critical response 's performance as Mamie Till garnered widespread acclaim. Audiences polled by
CinemaScore gave the film a rare average grade of "A+", and those at
PostTrak gave the film a 91% overall positive score, with 87% saying they definitely would recommend it.
Peter Travers of
ABC News felt
Till "is more than a movie—it's essential viewing." He further praised Deadwyler's performance, writing she "is too good to let a movie turn Black trauma into cheesy Oscar bait. Even when the film lets conventional biopic tropes mess with momentum, Deadwyler never loses her uncanny connection to the female warrior she's playing."
Manohla Dargis of
The New York Times highlighted Chukwa's fixed focus on Mamie Till, to which she also praised Deadwyler for "delivering a quiet, centralizing performance that works contrapuntally with the story's heaviness, its profundity and violence."
Michael Phillips of the
Chicago Tribune also noted Chukwa's direction and Deadwyler's performance, but felt more screen time was needed to justify "Mamie's transformation from relatively apolitical Chicagoan to an urgently engaged citizen of a wider world."
Richard Brody of
The New Yorker stated the film "is a work of mighty cinematic portraiture, with a range of closeups of Mamie that infuse the film with an overwhelming combination of subjective depth and an outward sense of purpose. These images depend for that vast spectrum of feeling upon Deadwyler's performance, one of the most radiantly, resonantly expressive to grace the screen this year." Brian Lowry of
CNN felt there's "a difficult-to-avoid aspect to the production that can't entirely escape a movie-of-the-week feel," but nevertheless wrote: "Anchored by Danielle Deadwyler's towering performance, it's a wrenching portrayal of reluctant heroism under the most horrific of parental circumstances." Peter Debruge of
Variety wrote: "It would take a tough constitution not to be moved by
Till, although that doesn't necessarily make it great drama ... Chukwu's first wish is clearly not to re-victimize Emmett Till, but in eliding such details and avoiding the torture, Chukwu relies perhaps too much on our imagination." Kate Erbland, reviewing on the website
Indiewire, gave the film a mixed response: "While Deadwyler turns in a remarkable performance as Mamie, beautifully calibrating her love and anger in one riveting package, the rest of
Till is prone to trope-ridden, predictable sequences that do little to advance her story or Emmett's legacy."
Accolades greets cast members
Jalyn Hall and Chukwu before a screening of the movie
Till on February 16, 2023, in the Blue Room of the White House Despite receiving nominations in several other ceremonies, Deadwyler was controversially not nominated for an
Academy Award for Best Actress at the
95th Academy Awards, prompting Chukwu to criticise the film industry for "upholding whiteness and perpetuating an unabashed misogyny towards Black women". In the wake of this decision, widely considered a snub, film critic Robert Daniels of the
Los Angeles Times lamented on how the film industry at large fails Black women, with the lack of a nomination for Deadwyler or
Viola Davis in
The Woman King serving to exemplify this. • – Shared with
Gabriel LaBelle for
The Fabelmans. ==See also==