When Tim Pickup returned to Sydney he resumed his career in finance with AMP, and with multiple clubs vying for his services, he resumed his career in Rugby League with the
North Sydney (#691). Pickup explained that Norths were the team that had suffered the longest drought between premierships, and he wanted to make a difference. His impact was felt immediately. Partnered with Keith 'Chicka' Outten in the halves, the tough but tiny pair made for a dynamic defensive duo, with Outten playing the organisational role in attack, where Pickup assumed the role of running back. With club stalwart Ross Warner, Keith Harris and the dynamic Bruce Walker in the forwards, and the rock hard playing surface itself, North Sydney Oval quickly became a formidable and dreaded place to visit. Although Norths fortunes improved during Tim's short time as a Bear, they never made the final five playoff series and hovered around the middle of the ladder, when coached by the great Noel Kelly for the 1973 and 1974 seasons. Their best finish was 6th, worst was 9th in the 12 team NSWRL competition. Personally Tim achieved instant success at representative level in 1972 and played for Australia after only 12 games for the Bears. Pickup was chosen for
City Seconds then played two games for
New South Wales (NSW #664), wearing no.15. Tim was a late inclusion to the starting side, replacing incumbent state and Australian pivot Denis Pittard. He made the most his opportunity and was chief architect in the 29-5 demolition of QLD. Pittard was given right of reply in the second game, but selectors decided go with the precocious 23 year old when Tim was named in the
Australian team (#462) alongside Norths teammate
George Ambrum. When first chosen for the Australian team, Pickup gave his first jersey to his Bears halves partner Keith Outten in recognition of his contribution to achieving the sports highest honour and his childhood dream. Tim played two
Tests against New Zealand in 1972 partnering
Tommy Raudonikis in the halves, and 'Ímmortal'
Bob Fulton in the centres, a combination which was regularly used by selectors over the next four seasons. Tim Pickup was the only North Sydney Bears player chosen in the 26 man squad when he toured Europe with the 1973
Kangaroos, captain-coached by Graeme Langlands. Tim played in 14 out of a possible 19 tour games, equal second most with Fulton, behind Arthur Beetson with 15. He also played in four of the five test matches, including the 21–12 First Test defeat to Great Britain at Wembley and the series decider in game three. Tim generally played at
five-eighth, though he was selected at
halfback in the 2nd Test against France. The 13th Kangaroo Tour was a huge success as the Australians retained the Ashes with a 2–1 series win over Great Britain, a 2–0 series win vs France, where Arthur Beetson became the first Indigenous Australian to captain an Australian team in any sport. The mighty Kangaroo's had an overall tally of 17 wins from 19 games. Their only other loss was against St. Helens. Tim's last Test Match for Australia as a North Sydney Bear was against the touring Great Britain side in 1974 series. He was named the Bears player of the year for the 1973 and 1974 seasons. Frustrated at North Sydney's policy towards player retention and its lack of ambition in recruiting star-quality players, Pickup decided it was time to move on and signed a massive (for the day) five-year contract to captain
Canterbury-Bankstown, (#406) who were known as the Berries at that time. ==Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs==