,
Ladinian stage (230 Ma). fossils (#1: South America, #2: Africa, #3: Madagascar, #4: Indian subcontinent, #5: Antarctica, #6: Australia). and a
syncline. • 1912, Wegener presents his ideas at the German Geological Society, Frankfurt .
Karl Erich Andrée (
University of Marburg) must have delivered him some references. • Note II: 'Petermanns Geographische Mitteilungen' is one of the leading geographical monthlies of international reputation. ; Wladimir Köppen (father-in-law), , , and Kurt Wegener (brother), , , defended there the Continental drift hypothesis in a somewhat mirror controversy (in ). • Note III: Although the climate distribution was not always similar to nowadays. In the
Carboniferous, coal mines are remains of the Equatorial Realm, glaciation remains are near the
South Pole, and between glaciation and Equatorial Realm (centered between latitude 30° and the
Tropic of Cancer and the
Capricorn) there are remains of
deserts (
evaporites,
salt lakes and
sand dunes) . These are consequences of the evaporation rate and the
atmospheric circulation. • 1912,
Patrick Marshall uses the term "
andesite line". • 1914, the idea of a strong outer layer (
lithosphere), overlying a weak
asthenosphere is introduced . • H. Jeffreys and others, most important criticisms , : • Continents can not "plow" through the sea, because the seafloor is denser than the continental crust. •
Pole-fleeing force is too weak to move continents and produce mountains. •
Paul Sophus Epstein calculated it to be one millionth of the gravity. • If the tidal force moves continents, than the Earth's rotation would stop after only one year. • • Its opening sentence is
Galileo's allegedly muttered rebellious phrase
And yet it moves. • Quote: "Daly,..., seeks to substitute sliding for drifting, assuming that broad domes or bulges form at the earth's surface, and on the flanks of these domes the continental masses slide downward, moving over hot basaltic glass as over a lubricated floor". (pp. 170–291) • Quote, translation: "The Alpine orogeny is the effect of the migration of the North African shield. Smoothing only alpine folds and nappes on the cross section between the Black Forest and Africa once again, then from the present distance of about 1,800 km, we have an initial gap of around 3,000 to 3,500 km, ie. a pressing of the alpine region, alpine region in a broader sense, of 1,500 km. To this amount must be Africa have moved to Europe. This brings us then to a true large scale continental drift of the African shield". cited in • W.A.J.M. van Waterschoot van der Gracht,
Bailey Willis, Rollin T. Chamberlin,
John Joly,
G.A.F. Molengraaff,
J.W. Gregory,
Alfred Wegener,
Charles Schuchert, Chester R. Longwell,
Frank Bursley Taylor,
William Bowie,
David White,
Joseph T. Singewald Jr., and
Edward W. Berry participated on a Symposium of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists (AAPG, 1926) Although the chairman favored the drift hypothesis, it ceased to be an acceptable geological investigation subject in many universities under the influence of book . • Quote, University of Chicago geologist Rollin T. Chamberlin: "If we are to believe in Wegener's hypothesis we must forget everything which has been learned in the past 70 years and start all over again." , • Quote, Bailey Willis: "further discussion of it merely incumbers the literature and befogs the mind of fellow students. (It is) as antiquated as pre-Curie physics". , • Bailey Willis and William Bowie saw the
sima with great strength and rigidity through the seismological studies, and tidal forces would act more on the sima (2800 to 3300 kg/m3) as it is denser than the
sial (2700 to 2800 kg/m3) . • Quote, W. Van Waterschoot van der Gracht (
Wilson cycle): "there may have been a pre-Carboniferous "Atlantic" that was closed up during the Caledonian orogenis" . • By the late-1920s: discovery of the
Wadati–Benioff zone by
Kiyoo Wadati (two pairs plus one paper, 1927 to 1931) of the
Japan Meteorological Agency, and
Hugo Benioff of the
California Institute of Technology. •
Alexander du Toit's book. • In 1923, he received a grant from the
Carnegie Institution of Washington, and used this to travel to eastern South America to study the geology of Argentina, Paraguay and Brazil. • 1931: Peacock named the
calc-alkaline igneous rock series. • • 1931, age of the Earth by the
National Research Council of the US
National Academy of Sciences. • • 1936,
Augusto Gansser-Biaggi interpreted rocks located at the foot of
Mount Kailash in the Indian part of the Himalayas as having originated in the seafloor. He brings back a sample with
Ammonites of the
Norian (
Triassic). He later interpreted this
Indus-Yarlung-Zangpo Suture Zone (ISZ) as the border between the
Indian and the
Eurasian Plate. • • January 1939: at the annual meeting of the German Geological Society, Frankfurt,
Alfred Rittmann opposed the idea that the
Mid-Atlantic Ridge was an
orogenic uplift . • •
Orogenic volcanism (
Pacific Ring of Fire) is dominated by
calc-alkaline igneous rocks (Calc series), lacking alkali-basaltic magmas (
Sodic series); whereas the
Mid-Atlantic Ridge (
extension) has mainly alkali-basaltic magmas . • sees subduction as the cause of Wadati–Benioff zone and volcanic activity, but does not link it to continental drifting. He was in a way an anti-drifter. • • Mid-1940s, paleontologist
George Gaylord Simpson finds flaws on the paleontology data. • Alexander du Toit,
Glossopteris findings in Russia are an erroneous identification. It was used as argument by anti-drifters . • 1944, cores of deep ocean sediment show rapid rate of accumulation, suggesting that old oceans are an impossibility ( cited in ). • 1948,
Felix Andries Vening Meinesz, Dutch geophysicist who believes in convection currents as a result of his work on oceanic gravity anomalies. Highly respected by H. H. Hess, Hess even got a chance to work with him. , , , , , • 1949, Niskanen calculates the viscosity under the crust to be 5 1021 CGS units. • • 1950, fading of the hypothesis from view. • • 1951, Alfred Rittmann shows that crystalline mantle is able to creep at its temperature and pressure and he shows
subduction, volcanism and erosion in the mountainous regions. , figure 4, p. 293. • 1951, André Amstutz uses the word subduction. • • • 1953, Adrian E. Scheidegger, anti-drifter. • E.g.: it had been shown that floating masses on a rotating geoid would collect at the equator, and stay there. This would explain one, but only one, mountain building episode between any pair of continents; it failed to account for earlier orogenic episodes. == See also ==