Todd Smith was met with "mixed or average" reviews from critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a weighted average rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, this release received an
average score of 51 based on 17 reviews.
AllMusic found that "the album proves that Cool James always has and always will have wit and style to spare" and while he "makes few pretenses to being street,
Todd Smith is straight commercial pop-rap," resulting into "solid radio-friendly hip-hop from a veteran of the genre." Michael Frauenhofer from
PopMatters described the album as "adequate [...] glossy, safe, front-loaded, and slick. My mom likes it, enough said. And the young-girl LL Cool J fans will love it too, regardless of what we say here. As for the rest of us? We can go home, we can play "
Mama Said Knock You Out" and "
Rock the Bells" on our stereos, and we can wait for his next inevitable metamorphosis."
Entertainment Weeklys Tom Sinclair criticized the album for its "big-name-guest-star-choked affairs" and wrote: "Too bad LL Cool J feels he needs the extra wattage, because
Todd Smiths best moments come when he raps alone, letting his inimitably confident flow shine. Some of these jams will no doubt click with the club crowd, but we wish our man would jettison the human baggage, team up with his old producer
Rick Rubin, and knock us out again." Similarly,
Rolling Stone critic Peter Relic remarked: "Eight of thirteen tracks on
Todd Smith qualify as slow-jam duets, and none of them has a sweat droplet of the appeal of 1987's LL-as-Lothario classic "
I Need Love" [...] leaving one wondering whatever happened to the immortal MC who could carry an album by himself without needing a breath." ==Chart performance==