Editor or author Vincent Ferré comments that early in the process of editing his father's unpublished writings, "the real nature of Christopher Tolkien's work was a matter of debate, before a more simplistic consensus began to prevail." In 1981, the scholar of literature
Randel Helms, taking that statement as definitive of Christopher Tolkien's editorial, indeed authorial, intentions, Christopher Tolkien disagreed, writing in the foreword to the 1983
The Book of Lost Tales, that the outcome of his work had been "to add a further dimension of obscurity to
The Silmarillion, ... about the age of the work ... and about the degree of editorial intrusion and manipulation (or even invention), is a stumbling-block and a source of much misapprehension." In the same foreword, while rebuffing Helms but without explaining why Helms's opinion was wrong, In Ferré's view, he should be thought of as "a writer in his own right, and not only as an 'editor' of his father's manuscripts". He gives two reasons for this: that
The Silmarillion reveals his own writing style and "the choices he made in 'constructing'" the narrative; and that he had to devise parts of the story, both to fill gaps and when "threads were impossible to weave together". Christopher Tolkien's editing of the 12 volumes of
The History of Middle-earth, using his skill as a philologist, created an editorial frame for his father's legendarium, and for the books derived from it. Ferré comments that this presented his father's writings as historical, a real set of legends from the past, in just the same way that his editing of
The Monsters and the Critics, and Other Essays presented his father's essays as scholarly work. In a 2012 interview with
Le Monde, he criticised the films, saying: "They gutted the book, making an
action film for 15 to 25-year-olds." In 2008 he commenced legal proceedings against
New Line Cinema, which he claimed owed his family £80 million in unpaid royalties. In September 2009, he and New Line reached an undisclosed settlement, and he withdrew his legal objection to
The Hobbit films. == Personal life ==