Critical response Tom at the Farm received generally favourable reviews. On the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 78% based on 72 reviews, with an average rating of 7.1/10. The website's critics consensus reads, "Taut, chilling, and overall engrossing,
Tom at the Farm offers further confirmation that writer-director Xavier Dolan is a filmmaking talent to be reckoned with."
Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned the film a score of 67 out of 100, based on 27 critics, indicating "generally favorable" reviews. In Canada,
La Presse critic gave it three-and-a-half stars, finding it distinct from Dolan's previous works, more
Hitchcockian, and praising
André Turpin's photography and how Yared's score complemented the story. Eric Moreault, also of
La Presse, gave it three and a half stars, writing that with its psychology, the film owed as much to
Ingmar Bergman as
Alfred Hitchcock. Kate Taylor wrote a negative review in
The Globe and Mail, criticising Dolan for reusing similar shots and questioning why Francis would become a social pariah rather than go to prison.
Peter Bradshaw of
The Guardian described it as an "intriguing [film] coiled with ardor and fear".
Irish Times' Tara Brady gave it five out of five stars and hailed it as a "work of genius", in which Dolan "transforms Michel Marc Bouchard's source stage play into a unique, enigmatic thriller".
Varietys Guy Lodge also wrote a positive review of the film, citing it as "Dolan's most accomplished and enjoyable work to date, ... also his most commercially viable". He praised the "glorious" score by Yared and the "gorgeous" cinematography of André Turpin. David Ehrlich in his review for
Film.com gave the film a rating of 7.7, writing that
Tom at the Farm is "seldom less than gripping as an exercise in suspense". Ehrlich also noted the score as "urgently bleating".
The Hollywood Reporter critic David Rooney reviewed the film unfavorably and criticised Dolan for being self-obsessed. He wrote, "It's also hard to take the film seriously when scene after scene explores the director's face with such swooning intoxication. Shots of Tom are held and held and then held some more—at the wheel of his car, in the cornfields, running in slow motion with his blond locks dancing in the breeze, sitting pensively on a bed in his underwear, or looking out through a screen door as a single tear streaks his face, like
Anne Hathaway in
Les Miserables". Dolan replied to Rooney in a
tweet: "You can kiss my narcissistic ass".
Accolades In nominations,
Tom at the Farm was a major contender at the
2nd Canadian Screen Awards, where it was competing for
Best Motion Picture. Dolan was a favourite at the
17th Jutra Awards, where his films
Tom at the Farm and
Mommy were pitted against each other in several categories, including
Best Film. ==References==