MLL career Schreiber was selected 1st overall in the
2014 Major League Lacrosse draft by the
Ohio Machine. He was named league MVP in both the 2016 and 2017 seasons while leading the Ohio Machine to the MLL championship game in both seasons and winning the championship in 2017.
NLL career Schreiber signed as an unrestricted free agent with the
Toronto Rock on October 3, 2016, having never played box lacrosse before and scored 94 points during his first season in the
National Lacrosse League on his way to being named NLL Rookie of the Year. In 2019 he matched his career high with another 94 point season. Heading into the
2023 NLL season,
Inside Lacrosse ranked Schreiber the #7 best forward in the NLL. During the 2023 season, Schreiber became just the second American born player to record 100 points in an NLL season. His nickname given by Canadian media is
Captain America.
PLL career In October 2018 it was announced that Schreiber was one of over 140 players who had signed contracts to play in the newly formed
Premier Lacrosse League. Following this announcement, Schreiber was assigned to the
Archers Lacrosse Club. Schreiber has topped the PLL Players Top 50 list three times, in 2020, 2022, and 2023. == Personal life ==