Disputed backstory Historians from the
Cherokee Nation, including Morningstar, have claimed that "Tom Threepersons" was an assumed identity, including his backstory about being the son of a Cherokee Chief, and that the birth name of this person is presently lost to history. The name Threepersons does not appear on the
Dawes Rolls. However, other historians stress that the Dawes Rolls would not apply to Tom Threepersons, because his family moved to Canada before they were recorded. These historians also stress that
Cherokee Nation participates in the practice of
oral history, and that practice should be to trust, but verify.
The tale of Threeperson's youth Threepersons is said to have been born in
Vinita,
Indian Territory on July 22, 1889 to John and Bell Threepersons. It is unlikely he or his parents had Threepersons as a given name, as it is not a Cherokee name and no records exist of him under the name until after Blackfoot rancher
Tom Three Persons, who he is often confused with, became regionally famous for winning the 1912
Calgary Stampede saddle bronc competition. Threepersons is known to have pretended to be Three Persons on at least one occasion. Threepersons' family and that of his friend, Bill White, are said to have both moved to the
Montana-
Alberta border in the 1890s. He claimed to have attended
Carlisle Indian Industrial School in
Carlisle, Pennsylvania, but there appears to be no record of this. After returning from school, he is said to have rode the
rodeo circuit throughout
Oregon,
Washington,
Wyoming, and possibly
Colorado. Threepersons claimed that in 1907, his and White's fathers were killed during a fight with
cattle rustlers and that the suspects were arrested, but released on bond. He claimed to have tracked them to a
saloon, where he confronted both suspects and killed them during a shootout. He is said to have been arrested for murder but later acquitted. There is no record of any of this occurring, and the story bears a resemblance to a widely publicized story from the same year about a ranger named Frank Wheeler.
The tale of his Early Career Threepersons and Bill White reportedly joined the
Royal North-West Mounted Police and were stationed near
Calgary; however, no records show a Threepersons serving in the mounted police. Shortly thereafter the two were assigned to capture a gang of outlaws who had murdered an entire family. Threepersons and White tracked the suspects for five days through heavy snow toward the
Yukon River in
Alaska, having to abandon their horses and continue on foot, carrying their weapons and backpacks. On the fifth day, they encountered the gang of three men, and engaged them in a shootout, during which White and one of the outlaws were killed. The other two fled. Threepersons buried White then continued after the outlaws. Several days later, at a small settlement called End of the Trail, Threepersons located them. Rather than confronting them in the town, he located the
cabin where they were staying outside of town, and waited for them there. When they arrived, a shootout ensued during which both outlaws were killed. He moved to
Douglas,
Arizona around 1914, where he worked as a
cowboy. == Verifiable History ==