New York Giants 2023 DeVito was signed by the
New York Giants as an
undrafted free agent on April 29, 2023, shortly after the conclusion of the
2023 NFL draft. DeVito was waived on August 29 and re-signed to the
practice squad the following day. In Week 8, DeVito made his NFL debut against the
New York Jets, after an injury to second-string quarterback
Tyrod Taylor. DeVito completed 2-of-7 pass attempts and was
sacked twice, but scored the Giants' only touchdown on a six-yard run. DeVito was signed to the Giants' active roster on October 31. In Week 9, he entered the game against the
Las Vegas Raiders in relief of an injured
Daniel Jones and threw for 175 yards and his first NFL passing touchdown, as well as two interceptions. In Week 10, with Jones suffering from a torn ACL, head coach
Brian Daboll named DeVito the starting quarterback against the
Dallas Cowboys. DeVito threw for 86 yards, two touchdowns, and one interception in a 49–17 loss. In Week 11, DeVito started against the
Washington Commanders. He completed 18-of-26 pass attempts for 246 yards and three touchdowns, as well as being sacked nine times. The Giants won 31–19, making DeVito the first winning quarterback to be sacked nine times or more in a game since 1992. In Week 12, DeVito started in a 10–7 victory against the
New England Patriots. He completed 17-of-25 pass attempts for 191 yards with one touchdown. Following their bye week, DeVito led the Giants to their third consecutive victory, defeating the
Green Bay Packers 24–22. DeVito went 17-for-21 passes and 158 passing yards, throwing one touchdown with no interceptions, and rushed for 71 yards on 10 carries. Taking possession with less than two minutes on the clock, DeVito went 4-for-4 driving his team down the field for the winning field goal by
Randy Bullock as time expired. DeVito was named NFC Offensive Player of the Week for his performance. After a 24–6 loss to the
New Orleans Saints, coupled with a lackluster performance in Week 16, DeVito was benched at halftime in favor of Tyrod Taylor. In the Week 16 game against the
Philadelphia Eagles, DeVito completed 9-of-16 passes for 55 yards as the Giants trailed 20–3. Taylor was later named the starter for the remainder of the season. As the season progressed, DeVito quickly became a fan favorite, both for going from an undrafted third-string rookie quarterback and leading an underachieving Giants' team to some surprising success, and for being openly proud of his Italian heritage. He was given the nickname "Tommy Cutlets" in reference to his Italian heritage and from mentioning that, by living at home with his parents, he doesn't have to worry about "what I'm eating for dinner, chicken cutlets." DeVito won the Bud Light Celebration of the Year award at the
13th NFL Honors.
2024 DeVito opened the season as the third-string quarterback behind Daniel Jones and
Drew Lock. After a 2–8 start to the season, the Giants benched Jones on November 18 in favor of DeVito. In his season debut on November 24 against the
Tampa Bay Buccaneers, DeVito made 21-of-31 pass attempts for 189 yards and zero touchdowns as the Giants lost 30–7. Buccaneers' quarterback
Baker Mayfield also mocked DeVito by mimicking his Italian hand gesture celebration after Mayfield scored a touchdown to end the first half. DeVito sustained a forearm injury during the loss, which sidelined him for the Giants'
Thanksgiving game against the
Dallas Cowboys. On December 15, he started against the
Baltimore Ravens and completed 10-of-13 pass attempts for 68 yards before he was removed from the game after suffering a concussion. At the end of the regular season, it was announced that DeVito would be returning to the Giants for the 2025 season. However, on August 26, 2025, DeVito was waived.
New England Patriots On August 27, 2025, DeVito was claimed off waivers by the
New England Patriots as the third-string quarterback behind
Drake Maye and
Joshua Dobbs. On March 6, 2026, DeVito signed a two-year, $7.4 million extension with the Patriots. ==NFL career statistics==