Paul was undefeated in his first 27 fights with a record of 23-0-4. He defeated future Hall of Famer and reigning NBA world flyweight champion
Frankie Genaro on January 18, 1929, in Buffalo, New York, winning in a six round unanimous decision in Paul's home town of Buffalo, New York. In an important early career win on July 31, 1928, Paul defeated Johnny McCoy in a six round decision in Buffalo. He defeated McCoy again in a unanimous decision in Buffalo on August 14. In a distinct victory, Paul had Paluso down in both the second and sixth rounds. Three months earlier on April 12, Paul had defeated Paluso in another six round unanimous decision in Buffalo.
Victory over Johhny Datto, 1930 Paul's first clear win over Filipino boxer Johnny Datto came in a six round unanimous decision at the
Broadway Auditorium in Buffalo on January 1, 1930. Paul dominated Datto with a two handed attack in the third round which included vicious left hooks to the mid-section and punches to the chin. Datto lost the initiative after the third as well as the strength to mount much of an attack. With Paul taking the initiative in the last two rounds, Datto was merely the receiver of punches, though he attempted unsuccessfully to end the bout with a last haymaker. Paul had drawn with Datto in six rounds in Buffalo in their previous bout on November 8, 1929. On May 9, 1930, Paul would defeat Datto again in a second round disqualification from a low blow by Datto. The bout may not have ended as quickly for Paul, as Datto had floored Paul in the same round with a right to the jaw for a count of nine. On January 20, 1930, Paul defeated Eddie O'Dowd in a first round knockout at the Convention Hall in Rochester, New York. Paul commenced a furious hurricane of an attack in the opening minutes of the first round, and knocked out O'Dowd only 1:52 into the first round. Beginning with a stunning left hook, Paul threw lefts to the head of O'Dowd using foot work that had him bounding around with a spring in his step, finding new angles to continue to land his left. Two rapid lefts to the side of the head first put O'Dowd down for a count of nine, and when he rose, a studied left shot squarely to his chin ended the match. Paul defeated Archie Bell on January 24, 1930, in an important early victory at Detroit's Olympia Stadium in a ten round points decision. The Buffalo fighter's win was decisive over the older known veteran, with the referee giving Paul seven rounds, Bell one, and two even.
Wins, Panama Al Brown, Bushy Graham and Phil Zwick He faced the legendary reigning bantamweight champion
Panama Al Brown in Buffalo, New York on March 14, 1930, with the bout ending in a six round draw. He fought 1941 world featherweight contender
Phil Zwick in
Philadelphia on April 6, 1931, winning in a ten round unanimous decision. Paul defeated
Maurice Holtzer on July 21, 1931, in a ten round unanimous decision in Philadelphia. He won an easy decision against the talented Frenchman outboxing him throughout the bout, and dominating when the two men mixed it up in close fighting.
Bouts with Freddie Miller A few of Paul's best known matches against a future champion came against Freddie Miller with whom he had six fights, earning a record of only 2-4. Paul's first, and only complete victory over
Miller came on August 31, 1931, in a ten round unanimous decision in Buffalo. Paul had lost twice to Miller in previous bouts. In one of his most complete and skillfully planned victories, Paul continuously circled right around his southpaw opponent's deadly, accurate left hand. The Buffalo boxer continuously scored with accurate rights, staggering Miller, even though his blows were not delivered with great power. At the opening of the tenth, Miller attacked Paul with a two handed barrage of blows, but Paul counterattacked and battered Miller groggy. On June 19, 1934, Paul defeated Miller due to a second round disqualification for a low-blow that dislocated Paul's hip. The late career injury may have influenced Paul to retire from boxing the following year. Paul had a good early start, showing more aggression and speed in the first three rounds, but Martin battered him in the seventh and the ninth. As a result of Martin's strong finish, the decision was not widely popular with the crowd. ==Featherweight tournament, Spring, 1932==