Initial reviews immediately following the film's debut at the Edinburgh International Film Festival were generally positive. The performances of the two leads, Mullan and Lowden, were widely praised. A few reviewers felt that the film may have tried to do too much due to having several themes, and a few felt that some of the golfing sequences were repetitive.
Review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes gives the film a 67% approval rating based on 83 reviews, with an average rating of 5.7/10. According to
Metacritic, which sampled 22 critics and calculated a
weighted average score of 56 out of 100, the film received "mixed or average reviews".
Screen Daily, while acknowledging the film's central father-son drama, also noted the portrayal of the class conflicts of 19th-century golf – played by the lower classes, attended by unruly crowds, and owned and bet on by aristocrats who controlled and profited from the sport. The review also opined that "As the principals play across the film's varied locations, in all weather, viewers get a true sense of golf's real grit, a more essential and raw essence of the sport than is achieved in most coverage today."
Kate Muir in
The Times concluded that the film is "fairly conventional, and your pleasure in it will probably be predicated on your love for the game." Conversely, Ross Miller in
The National called the film "emotional, inspiring and deeply heartfelt" and wrote "You don’t have to be a golf fan to be taken in by this engrossing, quietly passionate film that not only brings something new to the sports biopic table but also serves as a poignant, often heartbreaking portrait of paternal love and pursuing your passion with everything you have." In January 2017, Justin Lowe in
The Hollywood Reporter said the film "offers an engrossing and accessible celebration of the game’s modern origins, enhanced by striking locations and a standout cast." In November 2016 ''Tommy's Honour'' won Best Feature Film at the
2016 British Academy Scotland Awards (BAFTA Scotland Awards). Jack Lowden was nominated for Best Film Actor for his performance as Tommy Morris. ==Awards==