Muhle et al. (1991) reported that the responses to chronically inhaled copying toner, a plastic dust pigmented with carbon black,
titanium dioxide and
silica, were also similar qualitatively to titanium dioxide and
diesel exhaust.
Carbon black, one of the components of toner, is classified as "possibly carcinogenic" (
Group 2B) by the
IARC. As a fine powder, toner can remain suspended in the air for some period, and is considered to have
health effects comparable to
inert dust. It can be an irritant to people with
respiratory conditions such as
asthma or
bronchitis. Following studies on
bacteria in the 1970s that raised concerns about health effects resulting from
pyrrole, a contaminant created during manufacture of the
carbon black used in black toner, manufacturing processes were changed to eliminate pyrrole from the finished product. Research by the
Queensland University of Technology has indicated that some laser printers emit submicrometer particles which have been associated in other environmental studies with
respiratory diseases. A study at the
University of Rostock has found that the microscopic particles in toner are carcinogenic, similar to asbestos. Several technicians who had been working with printers and copiers on a daily basis were observed for several years. They showed increased lung problems. This confirms previous research published in 2006. Research at Harvard University has shown that, during printing, metal-oxide
nanoparticles (defined as 0.1 μm and smaller) are released into the air from toner-based laser printers and multifunction devices. These machines use toner particles that are on average 20 μm in overall diameter, but the surfaces of the toner particles themselves carry innumerable tiny metal-oxide nanoparticles. These ultra-small metal-oxide nanoparticles are highly bioactive and could cause harm to the lungs and also elsewhere in the body, given that particles 0.1 μm and smaller can cross biological membranes (including lung alveoli), thereby gaining access to all organs via blood circulation. This remains an area of active research, with many knowledge gaps. == Packaging ==