Critical Tonight received generally positive reviews from music critics. The album has a total score of 70/100 on
Metacritic, based on 32 reviews, indicating "generally favourable reviews". Critics often praised the album's sound and the instrumentation of the songs on the album. The album's sound was also subject to criticism by some critics, as well as the lyrics and album production.
Clash magazine commented that it could be "the band's most complete work to date. Worth the wait, and in all honesty better than we could ever have hoped for."
The Financial Post states that "
Tonight is the band's best album: Paradoxically, they've allowed themselves a degree of release from their characteristic tension by creating structures within which they can cut loose."
The Telegraph commented on how
Tonight: Franz Ferdinand is a melody-packed re-affirmation of everything that has made the band so popular hitherto, but with a highly contemporary-sounding, keyboard-driven edge.
The Trades stated that "this [album] is an evolutionary step for the band rather than a revolutionary one. Smart and danceable,
Tonight: Franz Ferdinand proves that Franz Ferdinand are the masters of dance-rock." NBC commented on how 'Franz Ferdinand has once again managed to outdo themselves with their best album to date.'
Uncut and
The Guardian reviews were less enthusiastic.
Uncut commented that the album sounds dry and superficial, and the songs are too similar to each other and other Franz Ferdinand songs.
Commercial The album had a significant chart performance. It debuted at number two on the
UK Album Chart, The album, however, suffered a fifty-place decline on the
Billboard 200 from #9 to #59 in its second week on the chart. The album also charted in the top ten in Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Spain, and Switzerland. The album had a chart performance similar to their second studio album,
You Could Have It So Much Better, which also charted in the top ten in several countries. In 2009. It was awarded a gold certification from the
Independent Music Companies Association which indicated sales of at least 100,000 copies throughout Europe. ==Track listing==