Upon its release by a third party on
YouTube,
Too Many Cooks became a
viral video, with
Rolling Stone calling it an "instant
cult classic". Director
Rian Johnson said that, "no joke",
Too Many Cooks should have been nominated for an
Academy Award for Best Live Action Short Film (although it was in fact ineligible for this honor, not having had a cinematic release).
Penn Jillette,
Simon Pegg,
Zach Braff, and
Richard Kelly all
tweeted their positive reactions to
Too Many Cooks.
David Sims of
The Atlantic wrote that
Too Many Cooks relied on "the classic
anti-comedy premise of taking so long with something that it goes from being funny, to being not very funny, to being boring, to suddenly becoming hilarious again. More than that, it's an excellent piece of non-narrative sketch comedy that sets out boundaries for its own weird reality and then goes about breaking them over and over again."
Julian Darius called it "a sublime postmodern masterpiece" and analyzed its metafictional aspects. Wesley Lara of
Bloody Disgusting wrote that "
Too Many Cooks is one of the strongest examples of transgressive programming on Adult Swim, taking full advantage of its environment to craft a memorable short that delivers both horror and comedy in an unusually successful manner." In 2022,
Rolling Stone ranked it the 10th-best TV theme song of all time, calling it an "
earworm" that is "somehow
every theme song, from every genre". ==Legacy==