The causes of the San Gabriel rebellion were complex. The rebellion originated from both the Gabrielino people's frustration at the Spanish mission's imposition on their traditional territory, as well as their oppressive rule over their culture, language, labor, and sexual life. Even the Neophytes (the Spanish term for newly baptized indigenous people) resented the poor treatment at the hands of the Spanish, and the colonists' suppression of their culture and ceremonies. Baptized Indigenous peoples within Spanish missions suffered labor exploitation and
second-class citizenship under the Spanish. In 1782, the Spanish governor ordered soldiers inside the missions to prohibit baptized Indigenous people from having any dances in their villages. In the fall they traditionally held their annual Mourning Ceremony, a culmination of a series of death rituals including dances. Through this practice, they believed that the souls of the deceased achieved release from the earth and entrance into the land of the dead. By the end of October 1785, Nicolás José—a Neophyte and key figure in the 1785 rebellion— and others at the mission seem to have concluded that the ban on dances was intolerable, and that their inability to carry out their rituals jeopardized the repose of their dead relatives' spirits. Nicolás José approached Toypurina, who was widely renowned as a wise and talented medicine person and whose brother was the head of her village. This kinship connection likely added to José asking for her aid. José reportedly gave her beads—as is customary to give a gift to doctors in return for their services —in exchange for her calling together a meeting of unbaptized Indigenous peoples from the area. Toypurina agreed, and contacted leaders of other villages to convince them to join the revolt. On the night of the attack, men armed with bows and arrows went to the mission. Toypurina accompanied them to encourage their will to fight; she was unarmed. While Toypurina was one of the people who led the revolt, the number of Spanish people at risk was small. She lived outside of the mission. Due to further growth of livestock and other factors of population, the numbers of people living in the area increased, leading to a double in numbers around the area of the Mission. Someone had betrayed them to the Mission guards, and the participants and ringleaders, Toypurina included, were captured. Spanish officials sentenced five of the attack's participants to twenty-five lashes, and another twelve to fifteen or twenty lashes. The punishments were carried out in public as a warning and lesson to all members of the mission. Toypurina, Nicolás José and leaders Chief Tomasajaquichi of Juvit village and Alijivit, from Jajamovit, were all put on trial. When questioned about the attack, Toypurina responded in a stinging statement that became famous: she participated because
[she hated] the padres and all of you, for living here on my native soil, for trespassing upon the land of my forefathers and despoiling our tribal domains. . . . I came [to the mission] to inspire the dirty cowards to fight, and not to quail at the sight of Spanish sticks that spit fire and death, nor [to] retch at the evil smell of gunsmoke—and be done with you white invaders! This quote appeared in Thomas Workman Temple II's article “Toypurina the Witch and the Indian Uprising at San Gabriel”. Other historians have argued that it is likely a mistranslation and an embellishment of her statement. According to the soldier who recorded her words, she said that she ‘‘was angry with the Padres and the others of the Mission, because they had come to live and establish themselves in her land.’’ Spanish officials convicted her and the three men of leading the attack. The three men were held at the prison (presidio) in San Diego, and Toypurina was held at the prison in San Gabriel while they awaited word of their punishment. In June 1788, nearly three years later, their sentences arrived from Mexico City: Nicolás José was banned from San Gabriel and sentenced to six years of hard labor in irons at the most distant penitentiary in the region. Toypurina was banished from Mission San Gabriel and sent to the most distant Spanish mission. ==Later life==