Colin Covert gave three and a half stars in his review for the
Star Tribune, adding that it was likely to shake up the viewer's opinions of
Star Trek fans. He praised the structure of the film, with the initial "shock value" of each fan being followed up with further background to round out the portrait. Renee Graham at the
Boston Globe gave a similar opinion, saying that despite the expectation of the reviewer, none of the opinions put forward by
Trekkies felt like a "
put-down". She summed up the documentary by saying "The Trekkie phenomenon may fall short of common definitions of normalcy, but as a film,
Trekkies sure beats sleeping outside for days to see a mediocre movie about some galaxy far, far away." Regarding some of the film's more eccentric characters,
The Tufts Daily film critic singled out Barbara Adams, a Star Trek uniform-wearing Trekkie that requests her fellow employees at
Kinko's address her as "Commander." Adams was ultimately dismissed from the Whitewater jury panel, not because of her Trek outfit, but for being interviewed after court by the TV news program
American Journal about her devotion to the
Star Trek television series. Also singled out by critics was
mullet wearing, 15-year old computer expert
Gabriel Köerner. Bob Stauss, the film critic for the
Los Angeles Daily News gave two and a half stars, saying that the documentary goes on too long and did not delve into the "real psychological issues raised by such obsessive interest". He added that the fans were "amusing for about 15 minutes, tops" and that the cumulative effect of watching the fans for that long was "numbing". James Verniere for the
Boston Herald gave three stars, suggesting that Nygard may have found his niche as the "
Michael Moore of weirdness" with this and his following film,
Six Days in Roswell. Verniere suggested that
Trekkies wasn't as definitive as the film
Free Enterprise (1999) but described it as an "interesting, often hilarious piece of sociological comedy". On
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a rating of 86% from 42 reviews with the consensus: "To fan or not to fawn over: this lifelong and prosperous journey into a sometimes cringeworthy world makes
Trekkies the lovable center of its universe." ==Sequels==