True Fire has been praised by music critics. Reviewing the world premiere, Mark Swed of the
Los Angeles Times wrote, "The performance was strong. Dudamel remained constantly attuned to Saariaho's vastly changeable instrumental colors, a cosmic sonic background for Finley, who handled each song with operatic intensity, part of a grand psychodrama of searching for meaning, for words that can obtain meaning through music but can also become emptied of meaning when sung." He added, "This is a profound, important work." Henry Schlinger of
Culture Spot LA observed, "...the orchestral writing was superb, plumbing the depths of the color and timbre, and the LA Phil pulled it off splendidly. Compositions like
True Fire have to be heard and seen in person; it is almost like performance art." Conversely, Donna Perlmutter of
LA Observed gave the piece a negative review, remarking, "
True Fire [...] was overly long at 30 minutes, considering its unrelieved, dirge-like stretches of doom and gloom. Singer Gerald Finley has had more grateful opportunities and the merely respectful audience buzzed with conspicuous naysayers afterward in the lobby." ==References==