The game received positive reviews upon release. In
GameFan magazine,
Dave Halverson (Skid) said "Konami brings the arcade thrill home" with "a beat 'em up blast-a-minute" that has "some of the best character animation you'll ever see" while Brody said it has some of the "most hilarious 2 player beat 'em up action ever" seen. Four reviewers of
Electronic Gaming Monthly gave the game positive ratings, praising the graphics and the animation, although there was criticism for the game being too easy and not having enough levels. Kirk Rutter of Mega Guide praised the game's action, graphics, and the two-player mode, but felt that
The Hyperstone Heist was similar to
Turtles in Time. Conceding that the action was fun at first, he criticized it for becoming repetitive and the difficulty for being too easy, concluding: "The lack of real challenge knocks a big dent in its lastability. But it's still a laugh."
Power Unlimited gave a score of 90% and recommended the game to those who are fans of TMHT, but criticized the repetitive gameplay.
ScrewAttack named
The Hyperstone Heist the
19th best Genesis game ever in their top 20 list, though they considered it a clone of
Turtles in Time, which they considered to be the best beat 'em up ever.
Complex ranked the game number 68 in their "The Best 100 Sega Genesis Games". ==References==