Executive producer
Manny Coto called "Twilight" the best episode of season 3. "Twilight" proved to be one of the most popular episodes of the series with reviewers and with fans. As
Enterprise was nearing the end of its first-run airings on UPN, the episode was chosen as the "#1 Fan Favorite Episode" in a Viewer's Choice poll at UPN.com, and rebroadcast in that context on April 8, 2005. In November of that year, readers of
Star Trek Magazine selected the episode as one of the Top Five episodes of the series. Jamahl Epsicokhan on his website ''
Jammer's Reviews'' wrote, "if I were a cynic I might say that I've already seen elsewhere most of what 'Twilight' has to offer." He wrote that the episode's dark alternate future bore similarities to the
Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "
Yesterday's Enterprise", and that Archer's memory issues were analogous to those in the film
Memento. Epsicokhan also suggested that the flashback sequences were similar to the
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode "
The Visitor", but was a "substantially less poignant take on hypothetical material". Nevertheless, he said that the episode "repackages the material well, plausibly ties it into the current
Enterprise story arc," and has "something for everyone," with an "apocalyptic" action storyline tied in to an "intimate character story that works in its own right." He gave the episode a score of three and a half out of four. Critic "Ex Deus" at
TrekWeb.com gave the episode 9.5 out of 10 stars, saying "Scott Bakula gives one of his best performances as Archer. The
Star Trek 101 guidebook named "Twilight" as one of the "Ten Essential Episodes" from
Star Trek: Enterprise.
The Digital Fix said this was the best episode in season 3. Blogger J.P. Halt at his website
Random Musings rated the episode 10/10, writing, "
Mike Sussman, who is arguably the show's best writer, has crafted a very smart script." Halt added: "Overall, this is probably the best 'reset button' episode the
Trek franchise ever crafted. It's one of a very small handful of outstanding
Enterprise episodes, and a contender for the series' best."
The Washington Post noted that "Twilight" was
Enterprise's "highest rated episode" in their analysis of ratings from the Internet Movie Database. Critic Stephanie V.W. Lucianovic at
Television Without Pity, aka "Keckler," said that the episode will "get your Heart of Khan pumping with righteous Trekkie excitement," adding that the producers have "come up with something amazing that is completely, unabashedly, and unreservedly worthy of high praise." She gave the episode a grade of A+.
io9 ranked "Twilight" as the 33rd best episode of
Star Trek, out of the more than 700 made by that time. Writer Darren Mooney at
The M0vie Blog.com says that "'Twilight' is a surprisingly affecting love story, one that uses a science-fiction premise to capture a very human situation." He added that, "
Mike Sussman is a writer with a very clear fascination and engagement with continuity and consistency... ['Twilight'] is a beautiful and thoughtful piece of
Star Trek, an absolute triumph."
WhatCulture ranked it as one of the "30 Best
Star Trek Episodes Of All Time," saying that, "like many great episodes of
Trek in the past, 'Twilight' had something interesting to talk about and did it exceptionally well... doing it within the confines of a mesmerizing character piece between Archer and T'Pol." Matthew Kresal at
WarpedFactor.com wrote, "
Mike Sussman's script for 'Twilight' is an intriguing piece of work." He adds, "It's also a turning point for
Enterprise as a whole and was the first sign of what the series might be capable of. On its own it stands out as one of
Star Trek best alternate timeline episodes and rightfully so." ==Home media release==