Formation and The Throes (2002–04) Adam Stephens and Tyson Vogel became friends while growing up in San Francisco, meeting first at the age of five and becoming friends when they were twelve years old. Each had received a guitar around the same time, and the two soon began making music together. Initially covering
heavy metal bands and the exploding
grunge sound of the 1990s, the two discovered
blues music independent of each other when they were around eighteen. The blues would make a lasting impression on them and their desire to make music. Stephens and Vogel played various instruments in various bands both together and separately throughout high school, but parted ways after graduation, With Stephens on guitar, harmonica, and lead vocals and Vogel on drums and vocals, Two Gallants began playing house shows around the
Bay area and
busking outside
BART subway stations, particularly the stop at 16th and Mission.
The Throes was a critical success, with
Pitchfork's Jonathan Zwickel calling the album "an electric, unforgettable listen," saying further, "Suffering only in its somewhat understated production,
The Throes could be considered a masterpiece of new American roots music. It's a heavy emotional investment, a struggle of the most fulfilling kind," and giving it a rating of 8.5 out of 10.
The Throes showcases Stephen's songwriting style, writing lyrics with influence from the blues. Songs on this and future albums would touch on social and personal issues such as domestic violence, suicide, abandonment, alcoholism, and references to fables of the
Old West and
antebellum South. The band released a 7"
vinyl single, "I'm Her Man", and expanded touring to support
The Throes. What the Toll Tells and Two Gallants (2005–08) Two Gallants signed a record deal with
Omaha, Nebraska's independent label
Saddle Creek Records in early July 2005. That same month the band began recording the followup to
The Throes at
Tiny Telephone Studios in San Francisco. In August of that year, Two Gallants played their first shows overseas in London as well as the
Reading and Leeds Festivals, and appeared at Saddle Creek's CMJ showcase at New York City's
Bowery Ballroom. Two singles were released from the album, "
Las Cruces Jail" and "
Steady Rollin'". Overall
What the Toll Tells received a "
weighted average" score of 71 out of 100 on review aggregation site Metacritic, indicating "generally favorable reviews". The album's storytelling did receive some harsh criticism from some critics, with Brian Howe from
Pitchfork saying the music "handles history like costume jewelry" and giving the album a 4.5 out of 10, On the other hand, Sharon O'Connell of the BBC's
Collective magazine praised this aspect of the album, saying the music "brims with an almost brutal rawness and betrays the pair’s striking talent for storytelling". Two Gallants toured Europe at the start of 2006 after the album release, played the Saddle Creek
SXSW showcase in March, and then toured the United States and parts of Canada throughout the spring, back to Europe for summer festivals, and another tour of the United States in the fall of that year, in total playing over 200 shows in 2006. The band continued to write and perform new material throughout the 2006 tour, sometimes taking months to get a song down while playing it live. Two Gallants began recording songs during interviews and soundchecks that they intended to be their next album. These songs were primarily acoustic, with sparse drums and occasional piano. After completing nine songs, the band decided the album was too dark, depressing and "heavy," releasing five of the songs as
The Scenery of Farewell EP on Saddle Creek in July 2007.
Two Gallants, the band's third full-length album, was released in September 2007 on Saddle Creek and debuted at number 29 on
Billboard's
Top Heatseeker's Chart. Produced by Alex Newport and Two Gallants at Hyde Street Studios and mixed at
Talking House Productions, the band's
eponymous album was noted for being much more sonically rich than previous albums while still retaining the same basic guitar/drum sound and storytelling themes, though
Two Gallants has more personal themes of love, loss and absence rather than the social themes found on
What the Toll Tells.
Two Gallants received a score of 69 out of 100 on Metacritic, "generally favorable reviews". A writer for
Alternative Press remarked that "their take on Delta blues and twisted folk is continually spot-on, going down equally well with a bad breakup or a cold beer with pals." Amanda Petrusich of
Pitchfork gave the album 6.9 out of 10, praising the album for "musically...offer[ing] the same blend of pseudo-Americana the band built its reputation on: a grainy mix of classic blues, folk, and electric guitar" but critiquing Stephens' lyrics, calling the writing "ambitious, heady, and riddled with histrionics". and the band toured throughout the fall of 2007 and into the spring and summer of 2008 in support of the album.
Hiatus (2008–12) After six years of constant recording and touring, Two Gallants took a hiatus starting in the summer of 2008, citing exhaustion both mentally and physically. Vogel formed an instrumental group called Devotionals with violinist Anton Patzner, cellist Lewis Patzner, Andrew Maguire on vibraphone, and drummer Jeff Blair. Devotionals is essentially a solo project, with Vogel writing and performing the songs. Devotionals released a self-titled album in 2010 on Alive Records. The hiatus was intended to take only around a year or so while the two worked on solo material to find their own directions, but was extended to such a length due to Vogel dealing with personal issues and Stephens being injured in an auto accident while on tour for
We Live on Cliffs in 2011. The van in which Stephens and tourmates were travelling in flipped several times, pinning Stephens' shoulder against the roof of the van and severely dislocating it. Stephens was unable to even hold a guitar for several months afterward, and the band was finally able to reunite in early 2012.
The Bloom and Blight (2012) After almost a five-year break between albums, Two Gallants released their fourth album,
The Bloom and the Blight, on September 4, 2012 on
ATO Records. Produced by
John Congleton,
The Bloom and the Blight is notably much heavier, with a more pronounced loud/soft dynamic than their previous work. The album received a score of 71 out of 100 on Metacritic for "generally favorable reviews".
AllMusic's Mark Deming described the band's new sound as "still clearly the work of just two musicians, and the performances reveal elements of the formal elegance of their early work, as if the grand scale of the sound has only reinforced the dynamics of the two-man band" and that the "music is as intimate as ever, and all the more powerful for it".
We Are Undone (2015) We Are Undone, Two Gallants' fifth studio album and second for ATO Records, was released in February 2015 and was available for live streaming in its entirety on
The New York Times' website. Unlike the songs on the first four albums,
We Are Undone was written almost entirely in the studio. The album was written and recorded at
Panoramic House studio in rural
Stinson Beach, California, a house converted into a studio where the band also stayed while recording. Previously the band wrote songs and worked them out while playing shows, sometimes over the course of years, but writing and recording simultaneously was "really refreshing," according to Stephens.
We Are Undone continued in the style of
The Bloom and Blight, focusing on a stripped-down sound and loud/soft dynamic shifts, moving further away from the punk-inspired blues of earlier records more into rock and roll. Similar to
The Bloom and Blight, critics continued to either praise this shift in sound or wish for the narratives and songwriting of previous albums. Zwickel from Pitchfork observed that "in its often inchoate roar,
We Are Undone bears little resemblance to the laser-focus punk-blues of their earlier work. The songs just aren't as good." However, Neil McCormack from
The Telegraph noted that "stylistic breadth and dynamic shifts make up for the stark brutality of their sound" and that "there is compassion and intelligence at work in songs of hard lives lived on the edge of collapse, romantically, financially and socially." == Music ==