Undercover: Operation Wintersun has garnered mixed reviews from critics; it has received a 57% and a 62.8% from
Metacritic and
GameRankings respectively. Criticism of the game focused on a number of different issues.
GameSpot referred to one of the game's first puzzles, where the player must pick up a potato from a garbage can in order to distract a crow so the player can listen into a conversation, as part of "a greatest-hits collection of maddening adventure-game absurdities".
IGN referred to the puzzles as "fairly logical and genuinely challenging" and
Adventure Gamers noted that although most of the puzzles were easy to figure out, some of them devolved into
pixel hunts, or just random clicking in the hope of finding the necessary object to progress. IGN focused its criticism on the game's voice acting, which it noted was "some of the least enthusiastic voice acting we've heard this year". GameSpot and IGN also both noted the game's tendency to be extremely buggy, with the game crashing several times toward the end of play. Praise focused on the game's unique storyline and high visual quality.
Adventure Gamers called the production values "reasonably high quality", and
GameSpot noted that despite the game's shortcomings, the
noir-style story kept its interest. ==References==