Meridiungulata might have originated in
South America from a
North American
condylarth ancestor, and they may be members of the clade
Laurasiatheria, related to other ungulates, including
artiodactyls and
perissodactyls. It has, however, been suggested the Meridiungulata are part of a different macro-group of placental mammals called
Atlantogenata. Much of the evolution of meridiungulates occurred in isolation from other ungulates, a great example of
convergent evolution. However, the argument that meridiungulates are related to artiodactyls and perissodactyls needs support from molecular sequencing. Some
paleontologists have also challenged the
monophyly of Meridiungulata by suggesting that the pyrotheres are more closely related to other mammals, such as
Embrithopoda (an African order possibly related to
elephants), than to other South American ungulates. Molecular sequence data from both collagen and mitochondrial DNA supports that litopterns and notoungulates are most closely related to
Perissodactyla (the group containing
equids,
rhinoceroses, and
tapirs) among living mammals, as part of the clade
Panperissodactyla, making them true ungulates, which has also been supported by some analyses of morphology. However, other morphological analyses have placed Litopterna elsewhere within Laurasiatheria. Didolodontids may be closely related to litopterns, and it has been proposed that they should be classified within Litopterna, but some analyses do not find them to be close relatives. Molecular sequence data from collagen suggests Notoungulata and Litopterna are more closely related to each other than to Perissodactyla, suggesting that at least part of Meridiungulata is monophyletic. By contrast, morphology-based analyses have found a range of possible positions for notoungulates. They have been found to be elsewhere within Laurasiatheria, within
Afrotheria, and as stem-group
atlantogenatans. A position within Afrotheria has been argued to be unlikely on biogeographic grounds, and some of the afrotherian characteristics present in notoungulates have been refuted. Litopterns and notoungulates are the only South American ungulates to have gone extinct recently enough for molecular data to be available, so the relationships of astrapotheres, pyrotheres, and xenungulates must be determined based on morphology alone. The clade Sudamericungulata has been proposed to encompass astrapotheres, notoungulates, pyrotheres, and xenoungulates but not litopterns. Such a clade had been found in previous studies, but left unnamed. The study proposing the name Sudamericungulata found them to be afrotheres. The study proposing Sudamericungulata was questioned in a later study, who suggested that the taxon and character sampling in the analysis was poor (including only a single perissodactyl), and that the placement of Sudamericungulata within Afrotheria was not robustly supported, and that a placement within
Laurasiatheria was supported for Sudamericungulata and Litopterna when Afrotheria and Laurasiatheria were constrained to be monophyletic by molecular results. A 2024 study based on morphology supported the monophyly of Meridiungulata as traditionally defined. == Evolution ==