Unspooled debuted at number 1 on iTunes Film & TV podcast rankings and number 4 on the iTunes overall top chart. The podcast has garnered many positive reviews in the popular press.
Esquire called it one of the best podcasts of 2019.
Rolling Stone wrote that the show was "wildly entertaining" and ranked the show as one of the best podcasts of 2020.
Town & Country Magazine lauded it as a "sharp, funny series…[with] charming chemistry," and
Vanity Fair noted that the show's "fresh and intriguing takes on venerable movies make for entertaining listening."
Vulture called it "funny and accessible." Another article in
Vulture noted that "
Unspooled is definitely among the best of [the good-film appreciation podcasts]."
The A.V. Club described it as "both serious and silly," and
The Hollywood Reporter listed the show as an essential film history podcast.
IndieWire said that the podcast "provides an interesting context for what does or doesn't remain timeless in the movie world."
Discover Pods referred to the show as "slightly more highbrow" than Scheer's companion podcast,
How Did This Get Made?, while
Emily St. James in
Vox complemented its "entertaining segments … [while being] dedicated to placing these movies in their proper historical context." Other critics have noted that the podcast is as an "absolute joy ... Scheer and Nicholson usually treat even the movies they don't care for with a measure of respect." The podcast has been recognized for its willingness to take a critical eye to respected classics. One review commented that the show "fuels discussions of whether these movies are truly brilliant, or simply just respected because no one has ever questioned them." Another stated more directly, "Amy and Paul are not afraid to make the point: Do you really need so many movies about Vietnam?" ==Episodes==