The film's immediate reception was less positive than Murphy's earlier works, although still positive. Locally the film was very commercially successful, being New Zealand's second highest-grossing film at the time (behind Murphy's previous effort,
Goodbye Pork Pie). Critically the film had a mixed positive reception. Filmmaker Costa Botes noted that “
Utu's shotgun approach to the great New Zealand film ultimately leaves it feeling episodic and tangled".
New Yorker film critic Pauline Kael however gave the film an exceptionally positive review, saying that "[Geoff Murphy] seems to be directing with a grin on his face, [...] the ferocity of these skirmishes and raids is played off against an Arcadian beauty that makes your head swim". Similarly
Variety said "Murphy has produced powerful images and strong performances". The film prompted public discussion about New Zealand history. Film academic Roger Horrocks said "Utu was an uneven film but succeeded in stirring up more discussion of New Zealand history than any recent book has done". ==Original Score Track listing==