In a review at
Tor.com, Michael M. Jones described
V-S Day as "thoughtful and fascinating, [and] as entertaining and well-executed an alternate history as you’re going to find." Jones praised Steele's historical research, his use of historical figures, and the way he works the story into "the cracks of established history". Jones also complimented Steele on his handling of the book's technical content. He said Steele "doesn’t dumb [it] down", but "has that same approachability and love for the mechanics that
Heinlein did." David Marshall wrote in the
San Francisco Book Review that "
V-S Day is an interesting alternate history novel" with some "very clever" concepts that are "full of possibilities". But he felt that it is "a less than riveting read, [which] is a shame." Marshall stated that despite the urgency of the situation in both the German and American camps, the book conveys "very little sense of threat". He added that despite being forced to work as fast as they can, both teams manage build a plane that "works perfectly the first time", and fires it "into the right place at the right time." Marshall concluded: "Such triumphalism takes the edge off the tension." He gave
V-S Day three stars out of five. In a review of
V-S Day in
Locus, Russell Letson stated that while he found "Goddard's People", an early version of the novel, "minimally fictionalized journalism",
V-S Day "is a fully formed historical-procedural WWII drama". Letson said Steele gives more attention to von Braun than Goddard, but noted that the book is more about rival programs and new technologies than the characters. One disappointment Letson felt was that the book's outcome came as no surprise. He said the 2013 interviews with the survivors of Goddard's team made it clear what had happened long before the end of the book. Reviewing
V-S Day at
SFF World, Mark Yon found the novel "great fun ... unravelling ... what is real and what was almost-real". He liked the way Steele includes real people in his story, and noted that while Goddard was driven by patriotism, von Braun was driven by fear. Yon said that even though the story is wrapped up rather quickly, "the general feeling at the end is one of satisfaction." He concluded: "It's not the longest novel, nor the deepest", but readers who enjoy science fiction films from the 1950s, with "their rocket-sleds and their silver ... ships" will find
V-S Day "a searing blast of 'what if'." ==References==