Background The title track "Vice Verses" was first performed by
Jon Foreman at an acoustic benefit show on April 12, 2009. Foreman iterated to the audience that the song was not slated for release on the upcoming Switchfoot record,
Hello Hurricane, but would appear on the following record, saying "This isn't going to be on that record [Hello Hurricane], it's going to be on the next one... I think it's the title of the next one." On April 23, 2009, Switchfoot officially announced via
Twitter that the album that would release following
Hello Hurricane would be titled
Vice Verses. This announcement came on the heels of a Twitter post in which the band said they had recorded four albums' worth of material during the
Hurricane sessions and intended to release the records one by one. This plan was short-lived, however, with Foreman later stating that the band had "already replaced a lot the songs on Vice Verses with new songs" and that
Vice Verses was a departure from
Hello Hurricane. In October 2009, Foreman said that most of the songs were ready to go and "if the next record came out today, it would be called
Vice Verses." In December, bassist
Tim Foreman was quoted saying that the album was nearly done and that he thought it was going to be even better than
Hello Hurricane. However, nothing more was heard about the project until July 2010, when Jon Foreman and guitarist Drew Shirley said the band was aiming to complete
Vice Verses by the summer of 2011. On several occasions during the summer, the band stated that they were pushing for
Vice Verses to be a double album, but they eventually decided to scale the project back down to a single disc collection. During the
Hello Hurricane tour, Switchfoot began debuting new songs that were candidates for inclusion on
Vice Verses, for example in the summer 2010, the band played a song titled "Against the Voices", which Jon Foreman stated was "from the next record." On August 8, 2010, Switchfoot debuted a song titled "Dark Horses" at a show in Chicago. Foreman also played other new songs at his acoustic aftershows throughout the tour, including "Thrive" and "She Says (The Black Eyed Blues)". After the conclusion of the Hello Hurricane tour, the band members each took personal time off but very quickly resumed work on
Vice Verses. On November 21, 2010, Shirley tweeted that the band were "tracking new songs in the studio tonight. You'll see..." while the next day, Foreman simply tweeted "making vice verses."
Recording In January 2011, the band began the official recording for the project, announcing via email that they had enlisted
Neal Avron and
Mike Elizondo as producers for the album. Adam Hawkins, an engineer during the
Hurricane sessions, was also brought in to work on
Vice Verses. The decision to work with Avron was influenced by recommendations from other bands who have worked with him in the past. "Sean O'Donnell from Reeve Oliver, who's now in
Yellowcard, [and] Jordan [Pundik] from
New Found Glory [have talked up Avron]," explained Jon Foreman. "They're both just like, 'You gotta meet him, and you're going to work with him.' I'm really glad it worked out for both of our schedules to make a record together, it's been so much fun. I feel like everyone's pushed each other in a really good way." On April 6, 2011, the band tweeted that they were "going into the studio one last time to put the finishing touches" on
Vice Verses, with final mixes to come later that week. Final mixing was completed on April 13, with band photographer Andy Barron tweeting that he was "watching the band sit in a dark room in hollywood listening to #viceverses front to back." On April 9, 2011 Foreman debuted the
Vice Verses song "Restless" during a live performance. During a two-week stint in Canada in May, the band began to debut more songs from the record. On May 18 at the London Convention Centre, the band debuted "Restless" live in its full-band arrangement. They played "The Original" for the first time in Kingston on the 20th, and a reworked version of "Dark Horses" on May 23 in Winnipeg, MB. Two more songs, "Afterlife" and "The War Inside" saw play during the tour as well. The band continued to preview their material throughout the summer months leading up to the album's release, offering fans a chance to hear the lead single, "Dark Horses" at their Bro-Am event, and some other tracks during a tent event at the Alive Festival on July 1. The band premiered 11 of the 12 tracks on September 17, 2011 through
ESPN Music commencing with the match between Oklahoma and Florida State. ==Musical and lyrical content==