In 1985, Persico and several leading Colombo figures were convicted of racketeering charges. In 1987, Persico and underboss
Gennaro Langella were each convicted in the
Mafia Commission Trial and sentenced to 100 years in prison. In the separate Colombo Trial, Persico was sentenced to 39 years' imprisonment, Langella 65 years' imprisonment, and
Alphonse Persico to 12 years, on November 17, 1986. To run the family in his absence, Persico named his brother, Alphonse "Allie Boy" Persico as acting boss prior to his arrest. When Alphonse skipped bail on a loansharking charge, Persico named a three-man ruling panel to run the family. In 1988, he dissolved the panel and named Orena as acting boss until his son, Alphonse "Little Allie Boy" Persico, could take over. Orena had been capo of Little Allie Boy's crew. Although Persico made it clear Orena was a placeholder, he also granted Orena the power to induct new members and order murders on his own authority, powers rarely granted to an acting boss. When
John Gotti became boss of the
Gambino family in 1986, Orena was able to expand his criminal dealings with the Gambinos. He became a top earner in the Colombo family, and increased his influence with
Benedetto Aloi and his brother
Vincenzo, leaders of the Colombo Brooklyn faction. In 1988, he was described as an underboss of the Colombo family and living in
Cedarhurst, New York. In November 1989, Orena allegedly ordered the murder of Colombo mobster Thomas Ocera, who allegedly skimmed mob profits, had let police seize the Colombos'
loansharking records, and had supposedly killed an associate of Gotti. On November 13,
Gregory Scarpa, a Colombo enforcer and
FBI informant, strangled Ocera with a length of
piano wire. Most believe it was because of Orena's strong stance against narcotics that Scarpa, along with fellow mobsters
Carmine Sessa and John Pate, eventually turned against their boss. In 1990, Orena was accused of conspiring to poison a racehorse named Fins, a son of the famed
Seattle Slew, for insurance money as part of the larger
horse murders scandal. == Third Colombo War ==