Vincent & Theo received positive reviews from critics, and in 2023 the review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes gave the film a 90% rating based on 29 reviews. In 1990,
Peter Travers wrote that the film "is an Altman masterpiece" while
Owen Gleiberman wrote "
Vincent & Theo looks and feels like a half-baked PBS drama, and at two hours and 20 minutes the movie is hopelessly plodding." In 2015 Noel Murray wrote, "
Vincent & Theo masterfully illustrates the way artists enjoy the power to transform real life into a thing of beauty." The same reviewer wrote "Paul Rhys skillfully inhabits a character even more wretchedly unhappy than his brother, who at least has the consolation of his art, and Theo’s own incipient madness gives the film much of its unsettling tone." Desson Thomson wrote, "As Vincent, Tim Roth is, without a doubt, the best thing about this movie ... presents a soft-souled, black-toothed, endearingly tormented artist, willing to take his work as far as it can go."
Roger Ebert wrote "here is Robert Altman's
Vincent and Theo, another film that generates the feeling that we are in the presence of a man in the act of creation."
Vincent & Theo opens with historical footage of the March 1987 auction at Christie's of Vincent van Gogh's painting
Vase with Fifteen Sunflowers for a record-breaking price. The later scene of Vincent van Gogh attempting to paint sunflowers a century before the auction has been noted by several critics. Peter Rainer wrote in 1990 that "The scene where he destroys his canvasses in a field of sunflowers has an almost oracular power. In moments like these Altman gets so far inside Vincent's impacted agonies that the effect is almost dizzying." Roger Ebert wrote of "a remarkable scene in a field of sunflowers, where, as van Gogh paints, Altman's camera darts restlessly, aggressively, at the flowers, turning them from passive subjects into an alien hostile environment. The film is able to see the sunflowers as Altman believed van Gogh saw them." He was nearly unknown as a feature film director when, at 45 years old, he directed the 1970 film
MASH, which was popular, very profitable, and widely appreciated by critics. He then directed a series of critically successful films in the 1970s, of which the best known is probably
Nashville (1975). Few were profitable, and following
Popeye (1980) he had largely lost his access to major funding for feature films. The 1980s became a decade during which Altman "worked small" on low-budget films and returned to his roots directing for television.
The Player was both profitable and critically successful. The film was nominated for the
BAFTA Award for Best Film, Altman won the
BAFTA Award for Directing and was nominated for the
Academy Award for Best Director. Following its success Altman was able to secure financing for nine films from
Short Cuts (1993) through his final film,
A Prairie Home Companion (2006). == Home media ==