Film critics analyzing violent film images that seek to aesthetically please the viewer mainly fall into two categories. Critics who see depictions of violence in film as superficial and exploitative argue that such films lead audience members to become desensitized to brutality, thus increasing their aggression. On the other hand, critics who view violence as a type of content, or as a theme, claim it is cathartic and provides "acceptable outlets for anti-social impulses". Adrian Martin describes the stance of such critics as emphasizing the separation between violence in film and real violence. To these critics, "movie violence is fun, spectacle, make-believe; it's dramatic metaphor, or a necessary catharsis akin to that provided by
Jacobean theatre; it's generic, pure sensation, pure fantasy. It has its own changing history, its codes, its precise aesthetic uses." Margaret Bruder, a film studies professor at Indiana University and the author of
Aestheticizing Violence, or How to Do Things with Style, proposes that there is a distinction between aestheticized violence and the use of gore and blood in mass market action or war films. She argues that "aestheticized violence is not merely the excessive use of violence in a film". Movies such as the popular action film
Die Hard 2 are very violent, but they do not qualify as examples of aestheticized violence because they are not "stylistically excessive in a significant and sustained way". Writing in
The New York Times, Dwight Garner reviews the controversy and
moral panic surrounding the
1991 novel and
2000 film American Psycho. Garner concludes that the film was a "coal-black satire" in which "dire comedy mixes with
Grand Guignol. There's demented opera in some of its scenes." The book, meanwhile, has acquired "grudging respect" and has been compared to Anthony Burgess's
A Clockwork Orange. Garner claims that the novel's author,
Bret Easton Ellis, has contributed to the aestheticization of violence in popular media: "The culture has shifted to make room for Patrick Bateman|[Patrick] Bateman. We've developed a taste for barbaric libertines with twinkling eyes and some zing in their tortured souls.
Tony Soprano,
Walter White from "
Breaking Bad",
Hannibal Lecter (who predates "
American Psycho")—here are the most significant pop culture characters of the past 30 years... Thanks to these characters, and to
first-person shooter video games, we've learned to identify with the bearer of violence and not just cower before him or her." Morales argues that, similarly to
A Clockwork Orange, the film's use of aestheticized violence appeals to audiences as an aesthetic element, and thus subverts preconceptions of what is acceptable or entertaining. ==See also==