The League of American Orchestras reported Higdon as one of the most performed living American composers, in 2008. "Higdon's music is lithe and expert," wrote Robert Battey of the
Washington Post. "Jennifer Higdon's vivid, attractive works have made her a hot commodity lately," wrote Steve Smith of the
New York Times. Among less favorable assessments, Rowena Smith of
The Guardian said one of Higdon's most popular compositions,
blue cathedral, "is pure new-age fluff; undemanding, unadventurous tonality dressed up as a quasi-mystical experience by the addition of bells and chimes." Andrew Clements in the
Guardian gave a recording of Higdon's
Concerto for Orchestra a minimal one-star rating. He referred to the music as "American contemporary music at its most vacuous, a noisy mishmash."
Tom Service, also in the
Guardian also criticized
Concerto For Orchestra, writing, "The problem with Higdon's piece ... is that its flamboyant gestures ... function only as surface effects, without creating any real structural momentum." In a more positive review, Raymond Tuttle wrote that "even though the
Concerto for Orchestra is not remarkable for its melodic content, there is so much color and brilliance in Higdon's writing ... that few listeners will notice."
Awards Higdon received awards from the
Guggenheim Foundation, the American Academy of Arts & Letters (two awards), the Pew Fellowship in the Arts, Meet-the-Composer, the National Endowment for the Arts, and ASCAP. In addition she has received grants from the Pennsylvania Council on the Arts. Higdon has been a featured composer at festivals including Grand Teton,
Tanglewood, Vail, Norfolk, Winnipeg and Cabrillo. She has won the
Grammy Award for
Best Contemporary Classical Composition three times. The first was in 2010 for her
Percussion Concerto. The second was in 2018 for her
Viola Concerto. That concerto was part of an album dedicated to her music on the Naxos label,
Higdon: All Things Majestic, Viola Concerto, and Oboe Concerto, which also won the 2018 Grammy for Best Classical Compendium. The third was in 2020 for her
Harp Concerto. Higdon won the annual
Pulitzer Prize for Music for her
Violin Concerto (Lawdon Press), which premiered February 6, 2009, in Indianapolis. The Pulitzer citation called it "a deeply engaging piece that combines flowing lyricism with dazzling virtuosity". It was commissioned jointly by the Indianapolis Symphony, Toronto Symphony, Baltimore Symphony and the Curtis Institute of Music. ==References==