Lieutenant Commander McClusky became
Enterprise's
air group commander in April 1942. During the
Battle of Midway, while leading his air group's scout bombers on June 4, 1942, he made the critical tactical decision that led to the sinking of three of Japan's
fleet carriers, '
, ' and ''''. When McClusky could not find the Japanese carriers where he expected them, and with his air group's fuel running dangerously low, he began a box search and on the second leg spotted the steaming north at
flank speed.
Arashi had stayed behind to attack the submarine ''
, which had been harassing the Japanese fleet. Surmising that Arashi
must be following the main fleet, McClusky ordered a change in course in the same direction as Arashi''. This led him directly to the enemy carriers. McClusky gave the order to attack, which resulted in confusion, with both squadrons of 31 aircraft diving on the closest carrier,
Kaga. Doctrine called for McClusky's forward squadron to attack the more distant carrier,
Akagi, and the squadron behind his to attack
Kaga. Two simultaneous carrier attacks would have made it harder for Japanese
Zeros to respond. Lieutenant
Richard Best, who commanded the other squadron and was considered to be its best pilot, noticed the error and pulled out with two wingmen to attack
Akagi. Best scored a direct hit amidships and a wingman a near miss that disabled the rudder and rendered
Akagi immobile. The other 28 dive bombers, some of which nearly collided with each other, scored at least four hits on
Kaga, leaving it a burning wreck. As he pulled out of his dive, McClusky's plane was pounced on by two Zeros, which put 52 holes in his plane and a bullet through his shoulder. His gunner, ARM1C Walter Chocholousek, shot down one of the Zeros. His controls partially shot up, McClusky landed his plane on
Enterprise. The confused attack order was later explained as a radio error due to
multiple people speaking at the same time. McClusky had been a fighter pilot before becoming Air Group Commander and was familiar with dive bombing doctrine, as was Best. McClusky's decision to lead his squadron against
Kaga was in keeping with doctrine that allowed the on-scene commander to choose targets. Within minutes, three of the four Japanese carriers had been turned into burning hulks. Later in World War II, he commanded the
escort carrier . ==After the war==