Carey was a keen sportsman, and while at Oxford as a student, he was captain of the College Boat and won four sporting 'Blues' in
The Varsity Match between 1894 and 1897. In 1894 Carey was selected to represent invitational touring rugby team,
the Barbarians, and became forever linked to the team when he instituted the club motto: Although Carey never played international rugby for England, he was selected in 1896 to represent the British Isles in their tour of South Africa, after being nominated by his university along with
Cuth Mullins. Carey played in all four Tests against the
South Africans, and scored a
try in the opening Test at
Port Elizabeth. ==Writing career==