Scott's next appearance at first-class level came the following season, against a touring English side, and he again took a single wicket while failing with the bat. However, few of the Americans were successful, and the Philadelphians lost by an innings and 16 runs. In that year's Halifax Cup, played only between the Belmont,
Germantown, and
Young America Cricket Clubs, he was one of the most successful players, leading his club's batting and bowling averages. Right-handed, Scott was an
all-rounder, excelling at both batting and bowling—in 1887 he was adjudged best bowler in the competition and the following season named the best batsman. His older brothers, J. Irvin (James Irvin Scott; 1863–1930) and
Joseph Allison Scott, both also played for Belmont during the same period, and Joseph captained the club on several occasions. A student at the
University of Pennsylvania, Scott played cricket for the university regularly during the late 1880s. A Gentlemen of Philadelphia team toured England in 1889, with Scott a key member, although no matches were granted first-class status. He excelled with both bat and ball on tour, scoring two centuries—125 runs against Gentlemen of Liverpool and 142 runs against Gentlemen of Surrey, which also included a
ten-wicket haul. He finished the tour second in the team's batting averages, to
George Patterson. Scott began to play less frequently after the tour, and then, being used as an opening batsman, scored 31 runs in the second match, his highest first-class score. The second match was more notable for the performance of Australian
Sammy Woods, who took match figures of 15/87. Scott's final match for Philadelphia came against the touring Australians, and his last Halifax Cup matches came the following season. He had originally been named in the Philadelphians' team for their
1897 tour of England, but he withdrew, and was replaced by
Herbert Clark. Scott died of pneumonia in
Colorado Springs in October 1907, though it is unclear in what circumstances he had come to
Colorado. His obituary in the ''
Wisden Cricketers' Almanack'' described him as "a careful and good class batsman, a fine field, a very useful slow bowler". ==Notes==