Exodus from Saxony Walther and several hundred of the other dissenters came together under the leadership of a pastor holding similar views—
Martin Stephan from
Dresden. In November 1838, under Stephan's direction, 800 Saxon immigrants ("Stephanites") left on five ships for
America in what is known as the
Saxon Lutheran Migration, hoping for the
freedom to practice their religious beliefs. The settlers arrived in
New Orleans on January 5, 1839. The group settled both in
St. Louis, Missouri, and to the south along the
Mississippi River in
Perry County, Missouri.
Controversy over Bishop Stephan Soon after the immigrants were settled in the new homeland, their leader and self-proclaimed "bishop of the new settlement", Martin Stephan, was accused of financial and sexual misconduct (charges he had also faced in Saxony) and was expelled from the settlement. His departure left Walther as one of leading clergymen remaining.
The Altenburg Debate After the fall of Stephan, the group of immigrants was deeply disturbed and unsure whether they were still a Lutheran congregation after having left the authorities and church hierarchy in Germany behind. Walther, who was originally called to be the pastor of a dual parish in the Perry County settlements of
Dresden and
Johannisberg, struggled over the questions that the laity and other pastors were also asking. In April 1841, soon after his brother Otto Herman, who was pastor of the congregation in St. Louis, had died, a public debate was held between Walther and attorney Marbach, one of the lay leaders of the settlers, in what is known as the "Altenburg Debate". Walther convinced Marbach and most of the other colonists that they could validly consider themselves to be a church. He then accepted the call to his brother's congregation in St. Louis, Trinity Lutheran Church, and served that congregation from May 1841 until his death.
Walther's ministry During his forty years of work in the LCMS, Walther held several key positions. A
log cabin college, which Walther helped to found, opened in December 1839 in Altenburg and eventually developed into
Concordia Seminary in St. Louis. Walther became its first president and held that position for the remainder of his life. On April 26, 1847, the Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod was founded. Walther served as its first president, a position he held from 1847 to 1850 and again from 1864 to 1878. In 1861, he also became president of the synod's "practical" seminary (today's
Concordia Theological Seminary) while it was co-located with Concordia Seminary for several years. He also founded and edited several Lutheran periodicals, including
Der Lutheraner and
Lehre und Wehre. He wrote a number of theological books. Perhaps his best known work is
The Proper Distinction Between Law and Gospel, which is a transcription of a series of evening lectures he gave at the seminary. He is also the author of the text and tune of the hymn "He's Risen, He's Risen" () found in the hymnals of the LCMS and other Lutheran bodies. Walther vigorously opposed the theologies of non-Lutheran
denominations in America and the influence of the major
secular philosophies and movements on Lutheran thought and practice, and defended the doctrinal and cultural heritage of the Lutheran Church. ==Works==