The basic design of FAST is similar to the former
Arecibo Telescope. Both designs had reflectors installed in natural hollows within karst limestone, made of perforated aluminium panels with a movable receiver suspended above; and both have an effective aperture smaller than the physical size of the primary. There are however significant differences in addition to the size. First, Arecibo's dish was fixed in a spherical shape. Although it was also suspended from steel cables with supports underneath for fine-tuning the shape, they were manually operated and adjusted only during maintenance. It had a fixed spherical shape with two additional suspended reflectors in a
Gregorian configuration to correct for
spherical aberration. Second, Arecibo's receiver platform was fixed in place. To support the greater weight of the additional reflectors, the primary support cables were static, with the only motorised portion being three hold-down winches which compensated for
thermal expansion. The antennas could move along a rotating arm below the platform, to allow limited adjustment of azimuth, although Arecibo was not limited in azimuth, only in zenith angle: The smaller range of motion limited it to viewing objects within 19.7° of the zenith. Third, Arecibo could receive higher frequencies. The finite size of the triangular panels making up FAST's primary reflector limits the accuracy with which it can approximate a parabola, and thus the shortest wavelength it can focus. Arecibo's more rigid design allowed it to maintain sharp focus down to 3 cm wavelength (10 GHz); FAST is limited to 10 cm (3 GHz). Improvements in position control of the secondary might be able to push that to 6 cm (5 GHz), but then the primary reflector becomes a hard limit. Fourth, the FAST dish is significantly deeper, contributing to a wider field of view. Although % larger in diameter, FAST's radius of curvature is , barely larger than Arecibo's , so it forms a ° arc (vs. ° for Arecibo). Although Arecibo's full aperture of could be used when observing objects at the
zenith, this was only possible with the line feed which had a very narrow frequency range and had been unavailable due to damage since 2017. Most Arecibo observations used the Gregorian feeds, where the effective aperture was approximately at zenith. Fifth, Arecibo's larger secondary platform also housed several
transmitters, making it one of the few instruments in the world capable of
radar astronomy. (Planetary radar is also possible at the Jicamarca and Millstone and Altair observatories.) The NASA-funded Planetary Radar System allowed Arecibo to study solid objects from Mercury to Saturn, and to perform very accurate
orbit determination on
near-Earth objects, particularly
potentially hazardous objects. Arecibo also included several NSF funded radars for ionospheric studies (
ionosondes). Such powerful transmitters are too large and heavy for FAST's small receiver cabin, so it will not be able to participate in
planetary defense although in principle it could serve as a receiver in a
bistatic radar system. (Arecibo has been used in several multi-static experiments with an auxiliary 100 meter dish, including
S-band radar experiments in the stratosphere, and
ISAR mapping of Venus.) ==See also==