Gladden became the pastor of the
First Congregational Church in Columbus, Ohio, in 1882 and served in that position for thirty-six years. During that time, he furthered his national reputation as a religious leader and as a community leader by his preaching, lecturing, writing, and active involvement. Its congregation included legislators and other persons with the power to address the social injustices about which Gladden preached. He preached two 45-minute sermons each Sunday. In the morning, he preached on living the Christian life. In the evening, he preached on social problems. The evening sermon was printed in
The Ohio State Journal the next day on page one. By the mid-1880s, he drew audiences across the nation to hear him speak for "bargaining rights for labor, a shorter work week, factory inspections, inheritance taxation, and regulation of natural monopolies." His goal was for "a gradual evolution toward a cooperative social order." He helped to promote his evangelical liberalism in books such as
Burning Questions (1890) and
Who Wrote the Bible (1891). In
Who Wrote the Bible, Gladden stated: "it is idle to try to force the narrative of Genesis into an exact correspondence with geological science." In 1885, he took part in forming the
American Economic Association and served on its council. The stated purpose of the association was "to support independent economic inquiry and to disseminate economic knowledge." In 1886, he traveled to Cleveland during a streetcar strike, spoke at a public meeting on "Is it Peace or War," and supported the rights of the workers to form a union to protect their interests. He also advocated public ownership of streetcars and public utilities. The more Gladden addressed social issues, the more his church grew: from 500 in 1883 to 1,200 in 1914. When members disagreed with him, rather than trying to bring them to agree with him, he sought to find common ground on which they could they stand together. In 1893, former US President
Rutherford B. Hayes presented Gladden for the position of president of
Ohio State University, but the board rejected him as "too pro-Catholic" because of his opposition to the anti-Catholic
American Protective Association. However, the
University of Notre Dame awarded Gladden an honorary doctorate for his stance. Gladden made several lecture tours to Great Britain. During the one in 1898, he defended the United States for entering the
Spanish–American War as "humane." His concern about social issues was grounded on his liberal theology that viewed the Church's mission as applying Christian values to secular institutions. Gladden served a term on the Columbus City Council between 1900 and 1902 and became an advocate of municipal ownership of public works. He also led a movement to change the elections in Ohio from October to November. Gladden's famous 1903 sermon "Murder as an Epidemic" condemned
lynching. In 1905, he made national news by denouncing a $100,000 gift to the Congregationalists from
John D. Rockefeller as "tainted." ==Later life==