2009–2014: Foundation and Melbourne Heart era After the dissolution of the
National Soccer League in 2003, brought about by the
Crawford Report, plans were drawn up for a new revamped national competition to begin the following season. Despite the calls for the new competition to feature two clubs from Melbourne, in 2004
Football Federation Australia, opting for a "one city, one team" policy, announced that the
Melbourne Victory had won the licence to be the only Melbourne club to compete in the new national competition, known as the
A-League. A 5-year moratorium was also established preventing any other expansion sides from the eight original A-League teams' areas entering the competition until the 2010–11 season, allowing Victory five seasons to establish itself in the Melbourne market. On 1 March 2008, former
Carlton Football Club vice-president and businessman Colin DeLutis expressed his interest in a second Melbourne A-League side, with an approach to the FFA to become sole owner of the second licence with the bid name of 'Melbourne City'. FFA chief executive Ben Buckley raised the possibility of expanding the A-League from eight to 12 teams in May 2008, in readiness for the 2009–10 season. Buckley also revealed the existence of a third Melbourne bid tentatively known as 'Melbourne Heart' backed by Peter Sidwell, to compete with the two other bids of Southern Cross FC and Melbourne City. On 25 July 2008, the Melbourne City bid dropped out of the bidding process leaving the Melbourne Heart and Southern Cross FC bids as the last two bids standing. By September 2008, the Melbourne Heart bid was awarded exclusive negotiating rights for the league's 11th licence, beating out the South Melbourne-backed Southern Cross FC bid. Negotiations continued until Sidwell's group was awarded the licence to join the A-League's 2010–11 season by the FFA on 12 June 2009. Heart started its
inaugural season against
Central Coast Mariners on 5 August 2010, at their home ground
AAMI Park, losing 1–0. The club's first ever goal was an own goal scored by
Ben Kantarovski in the Heart's second league game, a 1–1 draw against
Newcastle Jets. Melbourne Heart's first win was a 1–0 victory over
North Queensland Fury, which came in the fifth round of their first A-League season on 4 September 2010. They contested the first ever Melbourne Derby against
Melbourne Victory on 8 October 2010, and won 2–1. Heart finished their first season on equal points with
Newcastle Jets, but behind on goal difference in eighth position. They failed to make it into the top six teams to reach the finals, despite sitting in sixth position for majority of the season. After a moderately more successful second season, Melbourne Heart finished 6th on the ladder, enough to make the finals. Heart's first finals game was against Perth Glory, where they were defeated 3–0 at
nib stadium. Wins over local rivals continued to occur over the following two seasons, though the club failed to finish above the bottom two places and claimed the
wooden spoon in 2013/14.
2014–2019: City Football Group takeover and FFA Cup triumph It was announced on 23 January 2014 that the
City Football Group had acquired Melbourne Heart for $12 million. The deal involved CFG acquiring 80% of Heart, the other 20% to be held by a consortium of businessmen allied to
Rugby league club
Melbourne Storm. On 5 June 2014, the team obtained Spanish World Cup-winning striker
David Villa on loan from
New York City FC, another team owned by the City Football Group. Villa was expected to play in the A-League until New York City entered
Major League Soccer in 2015. Villa played only four of an expected ten matches, scoring twice, before being recalled by New York City. Although none of the matches were won, coach
John van 't Schip credited Villa with bringing attention to the new team, and it was estimated that his presence trebled the club's attendance. Ahead of the
2015–16 season, City Football Group announced it had bought out the remaining 20% share of the club held by a consortium for a $2.25 million fee, thus acquiring 100% ownership of Melbourne City Football Club. The men's team qualified for its first final of any kind in November 2016, and achieved silverware when it defeated
Sydney FC 1–0 in the
2016 FFA Cup Final. Despite this success, City continued to fall short in knockout finals matches, losing at the elimination or semi-finals stage of the series over successive seasons. van 't Schip left the club mid-way through the 2016/17 season to be with his terminally ill father and under the temporary stewardship of
Michael Valkanis the season ended with another early finals exit. Following van 't Schip's departure, City management signed former
Manchester United Reserves and
Wigan Athletic coach
Warren Joyce as manager ahead of the
2017/18 season. Despite overseeing improvements in the team's defensive capabilities, Joyce was unable to bring any silverware to the club. He left the club at the end of the
2018/19 season, in which the club again failed to reach the
grand final, though with a respectable winning percentage.
Fairfax soccer journalist Michael Lynch reported that, despite shoring up the team defensively, Joyce's "two years in charge will be remembered for the number of high-profile players who departed the club" under his watch, which included a falling-out with star striker Fornaroli, as well as the departures of
Neil Kilkenny,
Fernando Brandán and Australia's leading goalscorer
Tim Cahill. scoring for City in the 32nd
Melbourne Derby.
2019–present: Grand final appearances and maiden league double The club appointed Frenchman
Erick Mombaerts as manager ahead of the
2019–20 season, and further changes to the playing list occurred. Internationals
Florin Berenguer,
Adrián Luna and
Craig Noone were brought into the squad to add some attacking spark and former
Hibernan and
Brisbane Roar striker
Jamie Maclaren was signed as the club's marquee striker. Under Mombaerts City reached their second
FFA Cup Final, though they were convincingly defeated 4–0 by the home team
Adelaide United. The team rebounded from that loss to finish the season with its highest ever finish of second place, with 47 points. Maclaren won the
Golden Boot award with 22 goals and the club qualified for its first ever grand final by defeating local rivals
Western United, though were defeated 1–0 by the home team
Sydney FC in extra time. Mombaerts left the club in September 2020 and was replaced by his former assistant,
Patrick Kisnorbo. Under Kisnorbo, City had a record-breaking
2020–21 season by claiming the club's first A-League premiership, three games out from the end of the regular season. After winning the club's first A-League Premiership, Kisnorbo then guided a relatively youthful City side through the A-League finals series without several key stars to win the
2020–21 A-League Championship, beating Sydney FC 3–1. The club qualified for its inaugural
AFC Champions League appearance in 2022, and despite going undefeated they fell short of qualifying for the knockout stages. They rebounded to claim its second consecutive league premiership on the final day of the 2021/22 regular season, before being defeated by local rivals
Western United in the
grand final at AAMI Park. The club several personnel changes for the
2022/23 season and went on to claim its third consecutive premiership, becoming the first club in Australian domestic league history to achieve the feat, and second club for finishing 1st in three consecutive seasons. They lost their fourth grand final to the
Central Coast Mariners. The club qualified for the finals series in sixth place in the 2023/24 season, and were defeated in the elimination final. City finished the 2024/25 season in second place, behind newcomers
Auckland FC, and in so doing they ensured qualification for the 2025/26
AFC Champions League Elite tournament. The club comfortably defeated
Western United in the two-legged semi-final to reach their fifth
grand final in six seasons, against
derby rivals
Melbourne Victory. In a tense encounter, attacking midfielder
Yonatan Cohen scored the only goal of the match in the 10th minute, to record City's second men's championship. ==Name, colours and badge==