We Mean It, Man! received generally positive reviews. Writing for
Louder Than War, Robert Plummer named it his Album of the Week and called it "the most intensely focused album Gogol Bordello have ever made."
Spin called it "Gogol Bordello's most vital and engaging record since
Gypsy Punks."
Noizze UK's Sean Jolly, who gave the album 8 out of 10, praised its shift away from the band's characteristic frenetic style toward a tighter, more disciplined sound. Daniel Aaron of
The Needle Drop awarded the album 8 out of 10.
Spectrum Culture gave the album 4 out of 5 stars, characterizing it as an energetic post-punk record that moved away from the harder-edged guitar sound of
Solidaritine. Writing for the
Oberlin Review, Leo Slattery offered a more mixed assessment, finding the album somewhat disappointing relative to the band's back catalogue, while still recognizing it as evidence of the group's enduring vitality and willingness to experiment. ==Track listing==