The confusion over
Ras Mengesh's parentage is due to the fact that his mother
Wolete Tekle Haymanot Tomcho (
Woizero Tekle) was betrothed to
Dejazmatch Gugsa. On the death of
Ras Arya Sellassie, son and heir of Yohannes, the title of
Ras was conferred on Mengesha and the army of
Ras Araya Sellassie was transferred under his command. It was only on his deathbed, at Metemma, that Yohannes declared to
Etchege Tewoflos and the important dignitaries present that Mengesha was not the son of his brother Gugsa, but his. He thus acknowledged him as his son and declared him as his heir. Immediately after this announcement, close relatives of Yohannes, such as Fitawrari Meshesha, son of Maru, Yohannes's brother, and Dejach Bogale Araya, son of Ras
Araya Dimtsu, maternal uncle of Yohannes, refused to accept Mengesha as the son and heir of Yohannes, claiming that they were equally entitled to succeed the deceased Emperor. Since Gugsa had the same father and mother as Yohannes, the legitimacy of Mengesha would not have been affected if Yohannes had declared that he had chosen Mengesha, his nephew, as his heir. Mengesha, through his mother, had also additional claim to the Imperial lineage. The only reason for claiming Mengesha as his own son was simply to reveal the truth, which hitherto was kept secret due to the close association that had existed between Yoahannes's elder brother
Dejazmatch Gugsa and Woizero Tekle, the mother of Mengesha.
Augusus B. Wylde, a correspondent of the British paper,
The Manchester Guardian, who had been in Ethiopia as a member of the
Hewett Mission of 1884 and later, soon after the Battle of Adwa of 1896, contends that Mengesha was indisputably the actual son Yohannes. Bairu Tefla, on the other hand, although he is aware of the various sources, which assert that Mengesha was the natural son of Yohannes, has placed him as the son of Gugsa on the ground that "Most of the old people agree that Mengesha was the son of Gugsa, the eldest brother of the sovereign."
Familial rivalry and division of Tigray Even after the submission of Mengesha Yohannes, familial rivalry between the two lines of descent from Emperor Yohannes IV proved to be a difficult issue for Emperor Menelik II and his successors. Yohannes IV was survived by his elder "
legitimate" son
Ras Araya Selassie Yohannes and by his younger "natural" son Mengesha.
Ras Araya's son
Gugsa Araya, and Ras Mengesha's son
Ras Seyoum would for a time divide Tigray between them, with
Ras Gugsa Araya ruling the eastern half and
Ras Seyoum the western half. Eventually Mengesha's son
Ras Seyoum was made
Leul of all Tigray in succession to his father after the death of his cousin
Ras Gugsa Araya and after the treason of Gugsa Araya's son,
Dejazmatch Haile Selassie Gugsa. In 1935, Haile Selassie Gugsa joined forces with the Italian invaders when they
conquered Ethiopia and
occupied the country.
Ras Mengesha is regarded as the founder of one of the two senior cadet branches of the
Ethiopian Imperial Solomonic Dynasty. ==See also==