Both
Melody Maker and
NME named 'Whatever' Single of the Week.
Melody Maker editor
Everett True said the song "is absolutely f***ing stunning — from the strummed acoustic and
Rolling Stones-esque sentiments (''I'm free to be whatever I...whatever I choose
), the f***-off strings and inch-perfect handclaps, right through to the final applause." NME'' editor Tommy Udo wrote, "'Whatever' is only the best single of 1994, only the best Oasis single of 1994, because I feel reasonably confident that they'll do one better every time. Basically it pisses over everything else. A song to die for, with a descending scale and a f—ing string section: from '
Love Me Do' to '
All You Need Is Love' in under a year. The fact that it sounds like any number of other songs is a mark of the confidence that Oasis have in their songwriting: amateurs borrow, pros steal and look you straight in the eye, unashamed."
Music & Media commented, "Anyone who has attended one of their live gigs knows how well they do the
Beatles' '
I Am the Walrus'. Backed by a symphony orchestra they now have made their own seaworthy
Walrus."
Mark Frith from
Smash Hits gave the song a full score of five out of five, saying, "They've released this six minute epic complete with violins, sheep noises, hand claps and cheering, undoubtedly with the hope that all their fans will rush out and buy it, making it number one for Xmas." He added, "so, Christmas number three, I'd put money on it." ==Authorship dispute==