Diane Johnson in
The New York Review of Books summarizes the apparent
hypocrisies of California culture that Didion discusses in the book: Like all California children, Didion had been fed the old stories of California history, but when she eventually came to think about them, she could see they didn't 'add up.' The disjunction between myth and reality was too large, the basic paradoxes of the California psyche too obvious: mistrust of government while feeding at the troughs of public works and
agricultural subsidies; unchecked commercial exploitation of natural resources in the very footsteps of
John Muir; the decline of education from a place near the top of the nation to somewhere near that of Mississippi;
apathy, increasing rates of crime, and crime's related social problems. In
The New York Times Book Review, novelist and critic
Thomas Mallon wrote, "The more penetrating and idiosyncratic moments of 'Where I Was From' are the work of someone who can still be very much herself, someone who is even now, arguably, a great American writer." ==References==