The club's first team entered the
women's division of League1 Ontario in
2016. Their inaugural game resulted in a 1–1 draw with
North Mississauga SC. They finished their debut season in eighth place, out of nine clubs. In 2018, Darby added their men's team to the
men's league, which is one division below the top-tier
Canadian Premier League. Many of the players on their inaugural roster came from the prior year's
Durham United FA roster, as Durham did not enter a team for the
2018 season. Their debut match on April 28, 2018 was against the
Woodbridge Strikers and resulted in a 1–1 draw. In December 2024, the club announced the re-branding of their League1 Ontario team to Whitby FC for the
2025 season. == Seasons ==